Tobi’s PureLily One-Shots

Series Metadata

Listing Series

• I Know I’ve Loved You From the Start by 92sero (GomuGomu_No), BENINJAIL69, Macarono

  Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)  

  • General Audiences
  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • F/M
  • Complete Work

  23 Dec 2025

  Tags

  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie/White Lily Cookie | Saint Lily Cookie
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • White Lily Cookie | Saint Lily Cookie
  • Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Fluff
  • Romantic Fluff
  • Cutesy
  • Love Confessions
  • Minor Pure Vanilla Cookie/Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Cookie Run Characters Are Ambiguously Cookies or Human
  • White Lily Cookie | Saint Lily Cookie Needs a Hug
  • Pure Vanilla is romantically blind
  • Happy Ending
  • Short One Shot
  • Mutual Pining
  • Inspired by Music
  • Title from a Laufey Song
  • Inspired by a Laufey Song
  • I Wrote This While Listening to Laufey's Music
  • Song: From the Start (Laufey)
  • Writing Exercise
  • No beta we die like elder faerie cookie
  • I can't tell if I included angst or not in this fic
  • whoops
  • Romance
  • One Shot
  • Laufey References
  • No Angst
  • Wholesome
  • Rushed ending whoops

  Summary

  Ever since they were in the academy, White Lily Cookie had feelings for Pure Vanilla that she just couldn’t shake away. Now that the years have passed, her urge to confess has only grown further even though it looks like Pure Vanilla has a newfound interest in Shadow Milk. Unbeknownst to White Lily, though, Pure Vanilla just may have had those same feelings for her all those years ago. . .

  Or: Mutual romantic interest between Pure Vanilla and White Lily but nobody confesses until White Lily thinks he’s going to hit up Shadow Milk.

  Series

  • Part 1 of Tobi’s PureLily One-Shots

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  1,673

  Chapters:

  1/1

  Comments:

  7

  Kudos:

  31

  Bookmarks:

  2

  Hits:

  290