Work Text:
Ladybug wiped the back of her hand across her forehead, sweat beading down her skin. As a Ladybug, she figured the cold at times could have a negative effect on her internal body regulation, but she now wondered if the opposite was also true, because she was certain that this summer was going to be the death of her.
Finding a shady spot on a rooftop garden, Ladybug was relieved that the sun was finally starting to go down, and maybe some of the heat in the air might just go along with it.
Dangling her feet over the edge of the rooftop, Ladybug watched the passing parade of people on the street below. Many Parisians had taken advantage of Monarch’s absence over summer to picnic and enjoy the sunny days and warm evenings. She kind of wished she had taken up Alya’s offer to go with her and Nino to the swimming pool, but if she was being honest she was sort of trying to avoid seeing Adrien.
It was strange really. Adrien had always been kind to her (she doubted if he was ever unkind to anyone), but lately he’d been acting… different. Not in a bad way, just different. She could be wrong, but she was almost certain that he was paying her extra attention and his eyes - there was something in those emerald eyes that she couldn’t quite read, but it definitely had an effect on her body temperature. Now a year ago she would have been over the moon at such a development. No, scratch that, she probably would have panicked and run. Still, it would have made her heart race and fuled her daydreams of them one day getting married, buying a house and having those three kids. She giggled to herself at the thought. She still wanted those things of course, especially the three kids, but the man at her side in those daydreams now sported cat ears on top of a mop of messy blond hair.
Ladybug couldn’t say when exactly her feelings for Chat Noir had changed, it was something that snuck up on her so gradually she didn’t even realise how far she had fallen for her partner. Perhaps she had for a long time and just refused to acknowledge it, too afraid to admit her heart had betrayed her head. It was risky, far too risky to be on love Chat Noir. Logically, she knew that a relationship while Monarch was still at large could be dangerous to not just them but their families too. Deep down, Ladybug was terrified that only something bad could come from admitting how she felt, but on the other hand, now she couldn’t picture her life beside anyone else. Well almost.
No matter what happened, Chat stayed by her side. Even when Ladybug shided him, argued with him and left him out of the loop. Even when she failed as a Guardian, he never left her side and she saw that if that wasn’t love then nothing ever would be. Something she should be grabbing with both hands, and yet she still held back.
Ladybug was drawn out from her thoughts by the sound of two boots landing behind her and she smiled to herself. Turning she couldn’t help the way her heart skipped a beat at Chat Noir’s sunshine grin.
“Kitty.” She said, standing up to greet him. “I wasn’t expecting to see you tonight. Did your plans fall through?”
“Kind of.” He said, inviting her to sit back down with him on the roof’s edge. “One of our friends couldn’t make it, and I felt like a third wheel so I decided to bail out early and come and see you instead.” He gave her a shoulder bump with a cheeky grin, masking the disappointment he felt at said friend’s non appearance.
Chat looked out towards the Eiffel Tower in the distance illuminated by the orange and yellow of the sunset. Ladybug could hear the melancholy in his voice, and asked him if everything was alright. “Yeah, I guess so.” He said in a rather non-committal way. But the way his shoulders slumped forward didn’t match his words.
Adrien had been really looking forward to going swimming with his friends, and Nathalie had even pulled a few strings to get him the afternoon and night off and away from his father. Gabriel had been too busy for him anyway most of summer, so it wasn’t like he was missing out on much at home. His excitement had given way to disappointment though when Alya informed him that Marinette wasn’t coming, again.
Come to think of it, Adrien hadn’t seen Marinette at all over the summer break. This had been at least the second or even third time she had pulled out of something he was coming to. Was he the problem here? Adrien wracked his brain to think if he had offended her in some way before school ended, but he couldn’t think of anything.
“Kitty.”
Chat blinked and turned his head towards Ladybug, her eyes laiden with worry, but her smile was comforting. “I know what can cheer us up. Why don’t we get some ice cream? It’s been a hot enough day for it.”
Chat’s cat ears perked up. “What a purrfect idea m’lady.” He said excitedly. It wasn’t often that Ladybug offered to get ice cream together. “I saw Andre with his cart near the Trocadero when I was on my way over here.”
The two superheroes leisurely made their way across the Paris rooftops over to where Andre was serving up his world famous ice creams. Several couples were lined up, eagerly awaiting their joint ice creams representing their shared love.
“Oh, our two favourite superheroes!” Andre declared, holding his arms out and welcoming the two heroes closer to his cart with excited anticipation. “Are we finally sharing an ice cream together tonight?” He asked hopefully, his scooper at the ready. He really was Ladynoir’s number one shipper.
Chat chuckled and shook his head as he opened the zip on his pocket and took money out. “Two ice creams as usual Andre. M’lady here doesn’t like to share anyway.” He added with a cheeky wink towards her. Ladybug playfully slapped his arm.
“If I recall, you were the one who could down a whole ice cream in a single gulp. I don’t know how you didn’t end up with brain freeze.”
Andre let out a defeated sigh and began to scoop up Ladybug's ice cream. For a long time now, Ladybug was used to the same ice cream from Andre, mint green for his eyes and peach for his lips. If she was being honest, mint had never been her favourite flavour. It always felt like something was missing, but she was used to it by now. There was almost something comforting about knowing what you were going to get. Ladybug’s eyes soon grew wide though when Andre handed her a completely different ice cream.
“Um, th-thank you.” She stuttered, taking the new combo into her hands.
“Rich chocolate and peppermint, opposites that make a perfect blend.” Andre said to her with his usual flair.
Chat looked at the ice cream with curiosity before Andre handed him a combination he had never had before either.
“Cotton candy and blackberry, like a hug soft and sweet.” Andre smiled as he handed Chat the ice cream.
Chat wordlessly took the ice cream in his hand and looked intently at the pink cotton candy and blackberry combo. He knew who the ice cream was meant to represent - Marinette. Adrien had become well aware of the fact that for some time now he had been falling in love with his friend, but he could never get a chance to tell her.
It was frustrating really. Marinette truly was a comfort to him when she would just sit still for two seconds together, but half the time she would fluster and fumble or like today just not show up and he’d be lying if he didn’t say it hurt a little. She was never like that around other people, even when he was Chat Noir. So why was Adrien different?
He was still studying his ice cream when Ladybug tugged his arm over to where a vacant bench was so they could sit down.
“Looks like you got a new flavour comb, Kitty.” Ladybug said innocently. She was sure that before Chat had always had strawberry and blueberry which represented Ladybug, at least that was what she assumed.
Chat didn’t respond immediately, but took a lick of the blackberry ice cream on top. He remembered a few weeks ago when Marinette had brought a box of macarons to school to share. He had picked out a blackberry one, and it was delicious. Even just thinking about it now and the sweet smile Marinette had on her face as she held the macaron box up to him made his heart skip a beat. Maybe he did have a sweet tooth after all, and not just for ice cream or macarons.
Somewhere though in the back of Adrien’s mind something had felt vaguely familiar about blackberry ice cream. The only other time he had a different combination was when he had shared an ice team with Kagami, but that was peppermint and orange. Now that had been a weird combo! Hold up… that’s where he had heard it before. Marinette was blackberry, Kagami was orange and he was peppermint. Now he remembered!
“Chat?” Ladybug queried when he hadn’t answered. There was a goofy grin on his face and she wondered what he must have been thinking about.
Blinking the memory away, Chat looked at Ladybug and nodded his head. “Yeah, I guess the flavours have changed.” He said, taking another bite. As Ladybug watched him it wasn’t just the words he said, it was the softness in his voice and his eyes that hurt the most. It was the fact he was thinking about someone that was clearly not her.
“So… there’s someone you like?” Ladybug tried not to let her voice betray her disappointment. Of course Chat had moved on to someone else, she certainly gave him no reason to hold out for her. She was so stupid taking so long to realise how amazing her partner was.
Still, she couldn’t help but smile at the adorable blushy look on Chat’s face. “She’s a girl I go to school with. We’re good friends but I’ve just started to discover these new feelings I have for her. Maybe they were always there and I just hadn’t noticed.” He took another bite into the blackberry, a bit of the sweet cotton candy joining it now. It reminded him of the ice creams his mother used to buy for him when he was little and they would go on summer trips to the beach. There was something comforting about it, and the unique mix of flavours reminded him a lot of Marinette, although to be honest it reminded him a bit of Ladybug too. Maybe he hadn’t moved on as much as he thought. Chat then turned to Ladybug and pointed to her ice cream.
“What about you? If I remember right, your ice cream was always peach and mint.” Adrien might have discovered that he was falling hard for Marientte, but there was a place in his heart that still belonged to Ladybug and he couldn’t help his disappointment that the other guy had taken all her attention.
Ladybug took another bite of her unique mix of flavours. The chocolate was strong and smooth, but the peppermint danced on her tongue which she hadn’t expected. It was so Chat. Strong, confidant and completely unpredictable. There was something about it though that felt familiar.
“I’ve kind of been avoiding him to be honest.” She admitted to him. She laughed humorlessly at Chat’s surprise. “It’s not very nice of me, I know. We’re friends and I haven’t been acting much like one, but I guess I’m feeling a little confused about my feelings right now. I wouldn’t want to accidentally hurt him.”
As she took another bite it hit her what was so familiar, peppermint did reminder of Chat’s eyes, but it also reminded her of another green eyed boy - Adrien! That day with Kagami when they all went for ice cream he was the peppermint flavour. Oh was her heart really that confused that even her ice creams were being mixed up?
Chat nodded his head. “I totally get that. I wouldn’t want that to happen with…” He caught himself before he accidentally said Marinette’s name. “With Cupcake.” He said, feeling pleased with himself for the code name.
“Cupcake?” Ladybug chuckled. Well she figured it couldn‘t be worse than when she rehearsed her love declaration to Chat about a guy she called Buttercup.
“What?” Chat asked defensively. “I can’t tell you her name, and she kind of reminds me of a cupcake, all soft and sweet.” He laughed, but then his face then dropped a little. “I just wish I could see her and have a chance to tell her how I really feel.”
Ladybug felt a slight prang in her chest, but she really hoped Chat had finally found someone to be happy with.
“I’m sure you will Chat.” Ladybug smiled before dropping her head onto his shoulder and watching the stars as they emerged in the night sky. “And maybe I might even be able to as well.”
~~~~~
Alya knew that Marinette couldn’t be trusted to help herself. Nope, if she was going to make sure her best friend and Adrien would be in the same place at the same time, she was going to have to make sure Marinette had no idea he was going to be there. Nino, as always, was her willing accomplice for her new summer project - Operation: Ice Cream Date. They just had to wait for the perfect opportunity to put the plan in place, and today was going to be that day
Alya went around to Marinette’s to ask her if she wanted to come out shopping for the afternoon? Nino and her were having a movie date on Saturday and she wanted Marinette’s expert opinion on a new dress to impress her boyfriend. Alya watched Marinette and could see her trying to remember Adrien’s schedule. He was going to be at a photoshoot all afternoon for a new fragrance his father was selling. Perfectly safe to go out.
“I’d love to.” Marinette said with a broad smile. “At least the shops are air conditioned.” So she grabbed her bag and Tikki and headed out with her best friend for some retail therapy. After all, even a Guardian of the Miraculous needs a break now and then.
Meanwhile, on the other side of town, Adrien was playing basketball with Nino and Kim. What Alya knew that Marinette didn’t was that Adrien’s photoshoot had been cancelled when word came that the photographer had come down with a very nasty case of gastro. He’d invited Nino that day to come keep him company at the shoot, so when news came that it had been cancelled, Alya quickly put their plan in motion.
Since Adrien was now free for the rest of the day, he asked Nathalie if he could have the day with his friends. Nathalie was too frazzled to really care what he did at that point since the schedule for the shoot was already shot to pieces and Gabriel wasn’t even in town!
“Just make sure your bodyguard brings you home before 10 tonight, alright.” She cautioned before picking up her tablet and rushing over to talk with the publicist. Nino gave Adrien a high five and the boys quickly ran off to find their friends.
~~~~~
“You’re going down Agreste.” Kim said, bouncing the basketball from hand to hand. Sweat was pouring off his face as well as Adrien’s.
“Oh, you mean like this.” Adrien teased before side stepping Kim, intercepting the ball and dodging around the much taller boy to jump up and dunk the ball.
“That’s another point to Adrien.” Max called out as Nino blew the whistle. “That’s the game. Kim still wins by 3 points.”
“Ha ha!” Kim laughed in satisfaction. “Said I’d nail ya!.” He flopped down onto his back on the court and sprawled out his arms and legs. “It’s so hot out here. Whose dumbass idea was it to play out here today anyway?”
“Yours.” Max replied dryly causing both Nino and Adrien to snort. Nino sneaked a peek at a message that just came to his phone while Max and Kim debated the wisdom of playing basketball out in the afternoon heat.
Max’s AI friend Markov scooted his way over to Kim. “If you are feeling overheated, I recommend a cold beverage to cool your body temperature down.”
“Or how about some ice cream?” Nino interjected, pocketing his phone. He didn’t have a lot of time to make the rendezvous with Alya. Kim sat up and rested his arms on his knees.
“Yeah.” Kim said with a wide grin. “I could definitely go for some ice cream. Nice call Nino. What do you say, Agreste? Or is your old man still ruling your diet?”
Adrien reached out a hand and helped pull Kim up to his feet. “What he doesn’t know doesn’t hurt.” Adrien said with a cheeky grin. “And since you're the winner I guess the ice creams are on you?”
“Ugh…um…yeah, about that.” Kim muttered, scratching his head. “I think I left my wallet at home.”
Adrien laughed and patted him on the back. “Don’t worry my friend. I’ve got you covered.”
~~~~~
“Alya, why are we out here in the middle of the afternoon? It’s so hot.” Marinette whined as she and Alya took a seat on one of the river side benches. “I feel like I’m going to melt.” Marinette had helped Alya pick out a lovely yellow sundress to wear for her date with Nino and they even found some really cute shoes to match. Despite the sun still being out, Alya suggested a walk outside, but all Marinette was doing was getting sweaty and tired.
“You can’t live all summer cooped up indoors Marinette. You need some fresh air and Vitamin D on your face.” Alya said, taking off her sun hat and fanning Marinette’s face with it.
“I’m going to get a burnt face. I don’t tan like you do, I just end up looking like a lobster.”
“Oh look, it’s Alix.” Alya pointed, calling out to the skater. Hearing her name, Alix skated her way over to the two.
“What’s up?” Alix asked, fist bumping the girls.
“Shopping.” Marinette replied, wiping her forehead. “Alya bought a new dress.”
“Nice.” Alix nodded, chewing on the gum she had in her mouth. “Man, it's a hot one today. I was just going to go and find something cold to sink my teeth into. Know what I’m sayin’?” She gave Alya a sneaky wink.
Alya nodded, trying to hide the smirk on her face. “We could go look for Andre and get some ice cream to cool off.”
“Ha! It’s your lucky day then.” Alix said with an all too mischievous look on her face. “I just saw Andre over on one of the bridges. Come on, I’ll show you.”
Marinette was a little hesitant to go to Andre’s, but she really did need something to cool off with. “That sounds great. Let’s go.” She said, trying to hide her nerves. Surely she couldn’t get the same ice cream she did as Ladybug, could she?
Alya secretly shot off a text to Nino letting him know where Andre would be and the trio set off. Along the way, Marinette started to internally panic. What if Andre did give her the same ice cream she had the other day with Chat? How would she explain that one to Alya? Oh no, she was not telling Alya she was crushing hard on her partner. Nope, no way at all. She would never hear the end of it. Alya had always be a Ladynoir shipper and that could be a disaster, especially when she still hadn’t fully moved on from her crush on Adrien.
It didn’t take long for them to find where Andre was. The ice cream man was flat out, dishing up his sweet treats to the hot Parisians. Alya, Marinette and Alix joined the long queue to wait for their turn. As the line moved along, Alya caught sight of the Nino and the others heading their way. She kept Marinette distracted until the boys joined them, giving Marientte no recourse to run away.
“I didn’t expect to see you out and about today.” Alya said innocently. “What happened to your photoshoot?”
“It got cancelled last minute and Nathalie let me off the hook.” Adrien replied. He looked over to Marinette who was fidgeting behind Alya. Her cheeks were flushed red like she had been running. Poor thing, he thought, the heat must be getting to her. “Hi Marinette.” He said hesitantly. “How are you?”
“Oh, ah, I’m good, fine… great.” She flubbed with a too wide grin. Marinette chanced a glance in Adrien’s direction and her heart rate kicked up a gear at the soft look in Adrien’s eyes. She might have realised her feelings for Chat Noir, but oh boy did this particular blond still have an affect on her. Was she really that fickle?
“Kim, we’ve done this before. You know you can’t beat me on my skates.” Alix mocked, folding her arms.
“I’ve been training.” Kim retorted. “And I can beat you any day short stack.”
Alix moved into Kim’s personal space and pointed a finger up at him. “Say that to my face ya dumb ass.”
“How about I say it with my feet?”
“Oh you are on.” Alix emphasised, poking Kim in the chest. “Let’s do this.”
Kim and Alix took off down to the other end of the bridge with Max and Markov close behind them. Alya then pulled out her phone. “I’ve got to record this! Kim is going to burn so hard. Come on Nino.”
“Alya, wait up.” Marinette called, but Alya stopped her.
“No, no. You’ve gotten yourself overheated today and need to cool down. I’m sure Adrien will be happy to look after you.” She raised an expected eyebrow at the blond and Adrien’s eyes widened.
“Of course.” He said, happy for the opportunity to spend some alone time with Marinette. Then he started to backtrack. “That is if you don’t mind spending time with me Marientte.”
Her bluebell eyes widened at the realisation that Adrien had noticed she had been avoiding him in the wounded way he was looking at her. He thought she didn’t want to spend time with him. Well, that was partly true, but not in the way he clearly thought it had been. Her heart was in a muddle, and she didn’t know how to deal with it, so she thought avoiding him would be the best way to do that. Clearly now she could see that all she had done was hurt him.
“Of course I’d like to spend time with you Adrien.” She finally said with a genuine smile. Satisfied that the plan was working, Alya and Nino hurried after the others.
With everyone else gone, Adrien and Marientte rejoined the queue for Andre. Marinette fiddled with one of her pigtails while Adrien fidgeted with the ring on his finger.
“So…”
“Well…”
They both giggled and Adrien indicated for Marinette to go first. “I was just going to ask if you had been busy, over the holidays that is.”
Adrien rubbed the back of his neck. “Mostly I guess. My father has been keeping me busy and when I’ve had a chance to, I've tried to hang out with my friends.” Marinette winced at that wounded look again. She knew it was hard for Adrien to have time to spend with them. Some friend she had been. “What about you?”
“Oh yes, busy busy me.” She said with her usual over the top way. “You know me, designing, baking, helping my parents in the shop… yep, really busy.”
They spent the remaining time in a slightly awkward silence until it was their turn to approach Andre. The ice cream man’s face lit up like a Christmas tree when he saw them. “Adrien, Marinette! How delightful to see the two of you here. Are we finally sharing an ice cream together?”
Adrien chuckled and shook his head as he reached into his pocket. “Two ice creams today Andre.” He waved his hand at Marinette to put her money away, giving her a wink before handing his Euros over to Andre. Marinette couldn’t help the feeling of deja vu as she watched Adrien pay for the ice creams. If she didn’t know better…
“One cotton candy and blackberry for you.” Andre said, handing Adrien his ice cream. Marinette might have been imagining it, but she could almost swear Adrien was blushing, and why did that ice cream combination look familiar? Then her eyes widened. That was the same ice cream Chat Noir had, the one that represented Cupcake! But if Adrien was getting the same ice cream as Chat Noir, could that mean…? Marinette was all set to start panicking when Andre handed over her ice cream.
“And for you Marinette.” Andre beamed as he passed the cone over. “One rich chocolate and peppermint.”
Marinette took the cone, eternally grateful that Alya was in fact not here to see her get a different ice cream and start interrogating her, but the look on Adrien’s face was almost as terrifying. His eyes were fixated on her ice cream like it was going to jump out and bite him… and Marientte suddenly knew why.
If Adrien was Chat Noir then he knew she knew that his ice cream was Cupcake and her ice cream was maybe, sort of, almost the other guy, but what he didn’t know was that it really was him because he was the other guy but he was also Chat with whom she also had a major crush on and oh Lordy she felt like she wanted to faint!
“Um… do you maybe want to sit down, Marinette? You don't look so well.” Adrien asked tentatively. While he had fairly quickly put two and two together in his head about their secret identities suddenly being exposed, he pushed his own freak out to one side when he saw Marinette becoming pale.
Marinette didn’t say anything but wordlessly let Adrien (Chat!) take her hand and lead her over to where there was a free bench under a tree. For a while, neither of them spoke, eating their ice creams before they melted everywhere. Adrien kept chancing a glance across to Marinette, but she had her eyes fixed at the sunset in the distance. She must have known, he figured. There was no way you could write off both of them having the exact same ice creams as their alter egos at the same time.
“Marinette?” He asked softly, not quite daring to look at her.
“Yes Adrien.” She replied quietly, still not looking at him. Adrien licked his lips, the taste of the blackberry still on his tongue. He had to say something.
“So… I guess you still gave up on Buttercup then?” He asked, indicating to the ice cream in her hand. “The guy you liked you called Buttercup right?” It was a calculated risk, but he had to know for sure she knew who he was. Finally Marinette’s eyes turned towards him and he could see the shimmer of unshed tears in her eyes, but also recognition. She knew who he was, and he knew who she was.
“Not exactly Kitty.” She said, turning away from him again and leaving no doubt but using her pet name for him. Her voice was shaking as she spoke. “This wasn’t at all how I wanted us to find out our identities.” She lamented, dropping her head onto his shoulder and Adrien couldn’t help but smile at that. Marinette had never been that close to Adrien, but she was to Chat and a part of him hoped that was a good sign.
“So… what happened with Buttercup?” He queried, trying to sound casual. Now it was Adrien’s turn to avoid her eyes. Finding out that Ladybug was Marinette, their everyday Ladybug as he himself had called her, filled his heart to overflowing. But there was this Buttercup guy that her heart had belonged to for so long, and now some new person had emerged too. He didn’t stand much of a hope.
“Well, you’ll remember I said the other night I had been avoiding the other guy because I was feeling confused. See, I still cared a lot about him, Buttercup that is, but I also realised that I’d been falling in love with my best friend who also happened to be my partner.”
She lifted her head to meet his eyes and Adrien’s breath caught in his throat. Marinette smiled at him sadly. “The irony of the whole thing is, I just fell in love with the same guy twice.”
“Hold up.” Adrien exclaimed, turning more to face her. He dropped what was left of his ice cream and placed both his hands on her shoulders. “Are you saying I’m Buttercup?”
Marinette nodded silently. She turned away from him and Adrien’s hands dropped away from her as she let out a shaking sigh, looking down into the remnants of her ice cream cone. “I’m too late though right.” She lamented with a little shrug of her shoulders. “I mean, you like Cupcake now and I…”
“Do you remember that time…” Adrien interrupted, “we came here together, you, me and Kagami?”
Marinette blinked at him for a moment. “The Bourgeois anniversary? I remember.” She said, wondering why he would be bringing that up now.
Adrien looked up at the sky with a small smile on his lips. “That’s right. Andre offered us three different ice cream combinations, one for you and Kagami, one for me and Kagami and one more…”
“For you and me.” Marinette’s voice wasn’t much more than a whisper.
Adrien reached out and gently cupped her cheek in his hand. “Blackberry and peppermint, an explosive mix that’s a fact.” He recited, echoing Andre’s words that day.
“But oftentimes it’s the opposites that attract.” Marinette finished, her heart racing in her chest and Andre’s obnoxious little rhyme ringing in her mind. “But Adrien… the blackberry ice cream… does that mean…”
“You’re Cupcake m’lady.” He smiled, rubbing his thumb against her cheek. “I guess we were both a pair of idiots, because I fell in love with the same girl twice too.”
Without warning, Adrien suddenly leaned in and pressed his lips to hers. Feeling her stiffen under his hand, he almost instantly pulled away to see her wide bluebell eyes staring at him. Adrien felt a blush bloom across his cheeks.
“I’m… I’m so sorry.” He spluttered. “I should have asked you first, I should have taken things slower, I hmph…”
He was cut off when Marinette grabbed his face in both her hands and pulled him into a bruising kiss. Adrien’s brain almost short circuited at the ferocity of the way she kissed him, but he wrapped his arms around her, holding her tight to him, both their ice creams on the floor long forgotten.
The two were abruptly disturbed by the sounds of chuckling and the shutter noise of a camera. Breaking away from each other’s lips, they looked behind them to find Alya and Nino fist bumping each other with wide grins.
“You two cooked this up didn’t you?” Adrien laughed, pulling Marinette up to stand and wrapping an arm around her waist.
“Guilty as charged.” Alya beamed. “And I have zero regrets.”
Adrien looked down and smiled as Marinette looked up at him with loving eyes. Neither did they.