Actions

Work Header

Perceived Distance Shots

Summary:

i noticed a motif in the show of using close-ups on shane and ilya to trick the audience into thinking the guys are physically closer to each other than they actually are. it's really obvious in sochi when shane goes to check in with ilya. i thought it was a really cool way to convey the emotional distance between the two, so i broke it down here.

Notes:

debating turning this into a series. there's a few other scenes so far that use this trick (gym, both vegas scenes, showers) and i'm debating between analyzing the perceived distance shots separately or doing full breakdowns of those scenes considering perceived distance, costumes, mirrors, etc.

tumblr post

Chapter 1: Sochi Olympics

Chapter Text

the back of shane's shoulder fills the left half of the image. on the right side is ilya in profile.

So Shane sees Ilya at the top of the stadium and goes to check in. Since the back of Shane’s shoulder covers the right side of the screen, we the audience thinks Shane is much closer physically than he actually is. This parallels how Shane feels much closer emotionally to Ilya than he actually is, because Ilya barely offers any information about himself. The one time he tries to imply his home life is bad, Shane’s both too drunk and too naive to pick up on it. And then Ilya shuts down or deflects when Shane asks questions later on.

shane, framed from the chest up, fills the left side of the image. he's facing towards the camera and looking to the right of the image. the back of ilya's shoulder fills the right side of the image.

But we also get the same shot from Ilya’s point of view! Shane looks much closer to Ilya than he actually is because the back of ilya’s shoulder covers the right side of the screen. ilya’s far more aware of the distance between them, both physically and emotionally, and yet he still wants that closeness with Shane. Shane’s the only one asking if Ilya’s okay, the only one who is concerned for his wellbeing. We don’t even see Svetlana or Sasha doing that, and they’re Ilya’s childhood friends.

shane, framed from the chest up, fills the left side of the image. he's facing towards the camera and looking forward. the back of ilya's shoulder fills the right side of the image.

Then Shane steps forward, trying to close that distance between them, and Ilya rebuffs him. Ilya denies any connection between them. Ilya tells Shane to go away. Shane steps back, and does.

a wide shot showing shane and ilya on extreme ends of the image, shane on the left and ilya on the right. they are small in the composition with the rafters of a skating rink filling the rest of the screen. shane is walking offscreen and ilya is watching him go. the word canada is clearly visible on the back of shane's fluffy white jacket. ilya's in a black coat.

And we get this wide shot showing just how physically distant they are. I was shocked the first time I saw this because the previous shots really made me believe the two were standing pretty close together. Shane and Ilya have this connection that makes them feel close to each other, but there’s this huge gulf between them because in actuality they barely know each other. And yet they keep feeling drawn back together, and keep reaching out to each other across that gulf.

Also, Shane and Ilya are small in the composition. This is the most of rink we’ve seen so far in the show. Those two things underscore how hockey dominates both their lives and their relationship; hockey is how they connect and what’s keeping them apart.

Also also, notice how Shane’s been wearing his Team Canada jacket the entire time he’s in Sochi. Yet we never see Ilya in any Team Russia gear. And as is pretty common with their costumes, Shane is in white while Ilya is in black. Shane is Canada’s golden boy while Ilya is/will be Russia’s black sheep. Canada is Shane’s home while Ilya doesn’t really have one. 

ilya is facing away from the camera and is in the bottom right corner of the composition. he's small in the composition. the rafters of a skating rink fills the rest of the image.

ilya is looking to the left where shane left and is in the bottom right corner of the composition. he's small in the composition. the rafters of a skating rink fills the rest of the image.

Shane leaves, and Ilya’s alone and small in the shot, watching the figure skating down below. After a beat, he watches Shane leave. He pushed Shane away and still wants him there. We see Ilya pull up Shane’s text after literally pushing Sasha away as well to really underscore how Ilya wants that connection with Shane for more than the sex Sasha offers.