Work Text:
Reginald Fife was not stiff by nature. He was contained. Like a soda can someone had shaken vigorously and then told to “be normal.”
So when he asked Penelope Featherington to dance at his friend’s engagement party, it wasn’t romance it was survival.
Cressida Cowper had him cornered near the bar, nails perfect, smile sharp, asking questions that felt like job interviews for the role of Future Mrs. Fife. Reggie panicked. Spotted Penelope bright-eyed, laughing, blissfully unthreatening and blurted, “Do you want to dance?” while already tugging her toward the floor.
The band switched songs mid-step.
Baby, let’s dance…
Penelope looked up at him as Sara Evans filled the room, her smile slow and knowing. “That song choice feels intentional,” she teased.
“I promise you,” Reggie muttered, “nothing about this evening has been intentional.”
He was rigid at first. Counted steps. Overthought hand placement. Checked escape routes. Penelope, on the other hand, swayed easily, humming along, her body simply listening to the music like it trusted the world to hold her.
“Relax,” she said softly. “She can’t steal you while you’re dancing.”
He laughed. Actually laughed. Startled himself with it.
“Well,” he said, loosening his grip, “thank God for choreography as witness protection.”
By the chorus, his shoulders dropped. By the bridge, he was smiling. By the end, he realized too late that he’d enjoyed himself.
Which was, frankly, alarming.
~~~~~~~~
Their story didn’t rush.
They ran into each other at birthdays, weddings, accidental brunches. They became the kind of friends who shared fries without asking. Reggie stopped treating Penelope like an emergency exit and started treating her like a destination.
She saw him on his bad days, sarcastic, restless, pretending not to care. He saw her on her brave, vulnerable, heartbreakingly kind. She coaxed him out onto dance floors. He pulled her into spontaneous road trips. They met somewhere in the middle and claimed it as home.
Years later, at a backyard party string lights, cheap wine, laughter slipping into night someone hit play on an old playlist.
Baby, let’s dance…
Penelope froze mid-sip.
Reggie grinned. A real one now. Easy. Open. The kind of man who'd danced into himself over time.
“Oh no,” she said. “That’s our song.”
“Correction,” he replied, already offering his hand. “That’s the song where you taught me how to breathe.”
They danced on grass that wasn’t meant for it, laughing when they tripped, swaying when the music softened. Reggie sang along badly, enthusiastically while Penelope leaned into him like it was the most natural thing in the world.
Later still marriage, kids, life loud and beautiful they danced in the kitchen while dinner burned slightly and homework waited impatiently on the table.
The song would come on and Reggie, loose and joyful and entirely unafraid now, would spin her like a promise he was renewing.
Because once upon a time, he danced to hide.
Now?
Now he danced because loving her had taught him how.
And honestly—
that was the best rhythm he’d ever learned. 💃✨
Epilogue: Still Dancing
By the time the fourth child arrived, Reginald Fife no longer pretended to be surprised by joy.
He’d learned better.
The house told the story before anyone did finger-painted paper taped to the fridge, schoolbags flung like modern art in the entryway, toys breeding in corners despite regular extermination attempts. And somewhere, always somewhere, music.
The baby one year old, a girl sat on Penelope’s hip like she belonged there because, of course, she did. All soft curls and round cheeks and the sort of watchful eyes that suggested she’d be running the household by preschool.
“Don’t look at me like that,” Reggie told her. “I already know I’ve lost.”
Penelope snorted. “She’s got my timing and your dramatic pause. We are doomed.”
The older three children were sprawled through the living room in various stages of chaos. One arguing with the other two about whose turn it was to pick the music. Reggie let them fight it out character-building, he claimed until a familiar voice floated from the speakers.
Baby, let’s dance…
Penelope froze.
“Oh no,” she said, laughing. “Someone’s meddling.”
Reggie stood from the couch with the ease of a man who had long since traded self-consciousness for sincerity. He crossed the room, bowed just enough to make the kids groan, and held out his hand.
“May I have this dance,” he asked, “before civilization completely collapses?”
She passed the baby to the nearest responsible-looking child, a questionable choice, but one they’d made before and stepped into his arms.
They didn’t move much. . Just a sway. A familiar rhythm. The kind of closeness that came from years of choosing each other even on days when everyone was sticky and someone was crying for reasons that no longer made sense.
“Remember when you only danced with me because you were hiding from Cressida Cowper?” Penelope teased.
Reggie laughed a warm, unguarded sound, nothing like the man he’d been back then. “I thought I was escaping danger.”
“And?”
“I walked directly into my future.”
The baby clapped wildly from the sidelines, delighted by nothing and everything. One of the kids groaned, “Ew, they’re doing the song again.” Another rolled their eyes, but filmed it anyway, because this was who their parents were.
Two people who kept dancing.
Later, when the house finally quieted and the baby slept curled between them, Penelope rested her head on Reggie’s shoulder.
“You ever miss the old you?” she asked softly.
He kissed her hair, slow and certain. “Not for a second. That man didn’t know how to move.”
She smiled.
The music faded. Life would rev back up tomorrow school lunches, deadlines, spilled juice, love everywhere you looked if you bothered to see it.
And somewhere between chaos and calm, Reginald Fife would always find Penelope—
Waiting on the dance floor.
Fifteen Years Later (Still the Song)
The plan was technically Evelyn’s idea.
She was fourteen now old enough to be mortified by her parents in public, but wise enough to know their particular brand of ridiculousness was worth preserving. She’d grown up watching them dance through life like it was a private joke the rest of the world occasionally got to overhear.
For their parents’ fifteen-year wedding anniversary, she wanted to give them something that would last.
So she made a video.
Not a sleek one. Not trendy. This was archival. Anthropological. A loving documentary titled, in very serious font:
“Mom & Dad: A Study in Dancing (2009–Present)”
Her brothers helped, of course.
Miles, twelve, was in charge of digging through old phones and cloud folders, muttering reverently every time he unearthed a grainy clip. “Oh wow, Dad used to clap on beat. What happened?”
Jonah, nine, provided commentary whether asked or not. “This one’s from when Mom burned dinner but they danced anyway. I remember because we had cereal.”
And then there was the youngest—Lila, round-cheeked and determined. Her contribution involved aggressively tapping the phone screen, squealing whenever her parents appeared, and clapping like she’d personally choreographed the whole thing.
“See?” Evelyn whispered as Lila smacked the screen again. “She gets it.”
They found everything.
A shaky kitchen video where Penelope danced barefoot with a baby on her hip while Reggie spun her anyway. A living-room clip with Christmas lights and off-key singing. A hallway moment two seconds long caught accidentally, just hands linking, swaying to a song only they could hear.
And, of course, that song.
Baby, let’s dance…
~~~~~
On the night of the anniversary, Penelope and Reggie sat on the couch, wine forgotten, dessert untouched, as the video played.
They laughed first. Loud, helpless laughter.
“Oh my God,” Penelope gasped. “Why do I always dance like that?”
“Why do I look surprised every time?” Reggie countered. “Like joy caught me unarmed.”
Then—quiet.
Scene after scene of a life built not with grand gestures, but with movement. Choosing each other again and again. Choosing to stay in the room. Choosing to dance even when tired, even when unsure, even when the world felt heavy.
The final clip appeared.
It was recent. Grainy. Evelyn had filmed it secretly from the hallway. Reggie and Penelope swayed slowly in the kitchen, Lila between them, her tiny hands gripping their shirts while she bounced like she owned the place.
Text appeared on the screen, crooked but confident:
“You taught us that love doesn’t stop moving.”
Penelope cried first. She always did.
Reggie followed, because fifteen years with her had taught him that holding back was overrated.
“Well,” he said thickly, pulling his family closer as the kids piled on, “I suppose we’ve set a precedent.”
Evelyn grinned. “You’re welcome.”
And later—because tradition is tradition—someone pressed play again.
Reggie held out his hand.
Penelope took it.
Four kids watched, teased, filmed, clapped, and joined in.
Because some love stories don’t end.
They just keep dancing.
The End