1 - 20 of 160 Bookmarks by ihave_riddle
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
You run into a friend from college you haven't seen in years and think this could be an excellent opportunity to finally go out with him.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
12 Jun 2026
-
Egg-knock knock, who’s there? by sorryitsmyfirstdayonearth
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
14 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
Sam and you are drinking on Christmas, and when you suggest he use the magazine you got him as a present, you join him in the bathroom for some privacy.
Takes place after s3e8, “A Very Supernatural Christmas”
Series
- Part 1 of 6 days of Smutmas
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
10 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
When you go on a date with another guy, Sam finally gets up the courage to admit his feelings to you. Too bad the motel is too far away for the sudden heat rising between you two. Luckily, Sam borrowed his brother's car.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
10 Jun 2026
-
First Time [PodFic] by talltalesandbedtimestories (Drasna)
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
07 Jun 2026
Tags
Summary
He wasn’t concerned that midterms were next week, or that he had class in the morning. The only thing he was concerned about was making you feel safe and special.
Series
- Part 116 of Podfics in the Impala
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
07 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
you and sam were always close- really ever since you met.
youve seen each other at your highest and lowest, through apocalypses, demonic possession- everything
so why is he so mad at you for almost dying?Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
03 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
A collection of Imagines/Headcannons/Oneshots - whatever you wanna call it - featuring mainly the Winchester brothers.
*Many chapters will contain nsfw, but it's marked at the beginning of each. Also, I only write female reader.
Hope you enjoy!
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
30 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You and Sam had been inseparable ever since you were kids, but it all changed when you went to college. Just when you decide to come back home to your uncle Bobby, Sam walks back into your life.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
28 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Your crush on Sam Winchester was supposed to stay private.
Dean Winchester, unfortunately, has never known when to shut up.Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
25 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
During a Djinn hunt, Y/N gets captured and struggles to reconcile her dream world with reality. But maybe, she doesn’t have to.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
25 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
From sneaking beers from Bobby as children to tangled up in the sheets at a shitty hotel, you still aren’t sure how you got here but one thing you are sure of is that you are in love with Sam Winchester.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
21 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
It's been a long time for both of you and after offering a solution to the problem, you're surprised when he actually takes you up on it ...
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
13 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Secrets? Everyone has secrets.
Incorrect.
Sure, everyone has secrets. As in, lowercase "s", milquetoast, I-overheard-this-I-stole-that-I-cheated-on-them, civilian-ass secrets.
You? You have Secrets. The kind that you'd kill to protect (you have). The kind that you'd die to protect (just like your parents). There might never come a time when you can truly rest in peace.
...But in the mean time, why not make the best of the hand you've been dealt? And if you happen to find a kindred spirit along the way with almost as much to hide as you, well, who is the universe to stand in your way?
------
You and Sam meet at Stanford and get along like a house catching fire.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
02 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Sam, Dean and the reader go on a potential shapeshifter case. Sam and the reader are unofficially seeing each other and the shifter uses that and takes Sam's shape. angst ensues ...
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
02 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You're a half-vampire traveling with the Winchesters as part of a mutual exchange. Their protection (and watchful surveillance) for your knowledge on the inner workings of vampire society.
One night, while the three of you are staying in a motel, Sam returns to a sock on his and Dean's doorknob. Asshole. Oh well, he'll just join you in your room for a drunken movie night. Between friends, of course. What could possibly go wrong?
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
02 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Sam manages to get himself stuck in some magical handcuffs on a hunt. You offer to drive him back to the Bunker to use the tools there to solve this issue. And the whole time you're driving there? All you can think about is how hot it is that he's restrained.
You're sure Sam wouldn't go for something that renders him so helpless... or would he?
NSFW - Smut
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
02 May 2026
-
you should see the things we do in my dreams by thesundontshineontheseeyebrows
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
11 Jul 2026
Tags
Summary
Sam is harbouring a bit more than a major crush on you, and tonight you might just let him show you how important you really are to him.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
02 May 2026
-
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
02 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You are captured by a djinn and your fantasy world leaves nothing to be desired. Do you even want to leave?
(Rating for self-destructive themes, language, and explicit sexual content. See trigger warnings inside.)
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 15,410
- Chapters:
- 4/4
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 28
- Kudos:
- 302
- Bookmarks:
- 44
- Hits:
- 6,674
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
19 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
A truth spell hits the Reader and the Winchester brothers.
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
19 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
The hunt seemed normal enough when you agreed to join your close friends, Sam and Dean Winchester, but it quickly takes a turn when you have to go undercover as a witch. As tensions rise and danger unfolds, Sam finds it harder and harder to keep his feelings hidden- and so do you.
Based loosely on the song Abracadabra by The Steve Miller Band
Bookmarked by ihave_riddle
16 Apr 2026