Work Text:
The two of them were curled up on the couch, the apartment bathed in the slow spill of early evening light. Gem had one leg tucked under her and the other stretched across the cushions, wearing comfy leggings and a hoodie two sizes too big. Pearl sat upright beside her, posture composed even in leisure, hoodie sleeves tugged over her wrists, the neckline folded just so. Between them, Gem’s laptop hummed quietly, resting on a pillow and playing a dumb video they’d already seen three times. One earbud each. A shared moment.
They’d done this so many times it had become their own little tradition. Quiet evenings curled together, half-watching, half-existing in the bubble they made just by being there. Easy. Familiar. Close.
But tonight wasn’t like every other night.
Gem wasn’t really watching anymore. Her fingers played with the hem of her shorts, twisting the thread around her pinky as her gaze kept darting—first to the laptop, then to the golden haze outside, and finally to the digital clock blinking softly across the room. 6:21 PM. The sun was almost down.
We said we’d go out tonight, she reminded herself, heart flickering. Not just go out— a date . An actual, real, not-just-an-excuse-to-spend-time-together date. The first one.
The weight of that thought buzzed quietly under her skin. Not quite nerves, not quite excitement. Something electric.
She glanced at Pearl again, studying the curve of her cheek, the soft line of her mouth set in focus. She looked beautiful, even in a hoodie, even in the lazy light. Gem opened her mouth. Hesitated. Tried again.
“You wanna—”
Pearl turned toward her immediately, as if she'd been waiting. She didn’t seem startled. Just... nervous. Her hands were folded in her lap, but her fingers curled slightly tighter at the sound of Gem’s voice.
She met Gem’s eyes with the faintest twitch of a smile. “Should we go get dressed?”
Gem felt a grin rise up before she could stop it. “Yeah. Let’s.”
They moved at the same time and accidentally bumped shoulders. Pearl murmured, “Sorry,” under her breath, but Gem just laughed, nudging her lightly.
“Race you,” she said, and took off toward the bedroom.
Pearl lingered for just a second, eyes following the bounce of Gem’s curls as she disappeared down the hall. Her own smile deepened—soft, fond, laced with something that made her stomach flip.
The apartment felt different now. Still warm. Still them. But charged. Like the space between them had shifted, tilted, waiting for something neither of them had said out loud yet.
She exhaled slowly, then turned toward her old bedroom to get changed.
Tonight, something was going to change.
The door had barely clicked shut behind her before Gem yanked off her hoodie in one smooth motion and flung it vaguely toward the bed. It missed by a mile, landing in a crumpled heap on the floor. She didn’t look back. Her fingers were already at the waistband of her shorts, shimmying them down with practiced urgency.
Left in just her bra and underwear, she stood in the fading golden light, skin still warm from where she’d been curled up on the couch. The mirror across from her caught her reflection in full—bare arms, unruly hair, the slow inhale of her chest as she looked herself over.
She padded over to the closet, tugged it open, and began rifling through hangers like a woman on a mission. Dresses, tops, jackets—but nothing screamed first date . At least not the way she wanted it to.
One by one, she yanked out options and tossed them on the bed behind her. The pile grew quickly.
First came a black tank and skirt—safe, maybe too safe. Then a dress she’d worn once to a wedding. Too formal. A red halter that practically screamed I’m trying to get laid — too much. A lacy top that left her arms bare— too little. Then something soft, sweet and pastel. She barely got it over her head before frowning at her reflection. It made her feel like she was twelve again.
She stood in the middle of the room, arms crossed over her stomach, fabric everywhere, half-naked and already sweating.
Her bun from earlier had started to collapse. She yanked the tie out and groaned as hair fell into her face.
“Ughhh,” she muttered. “What am I even doing ?” Her voice cracked a little as she caught herself in the mirror. What if I overdo it again? What if she really thinks I’m not trying hard enough?”
She sank into her desk chair with a heavy sigh, limbs spread like she’d just lost a war. Her phone lit up as she opened Pinterest, thumb flicking through grids of gorgeous people in outfits that looked effortless and perfectly unachievable.
Hair. Focus on your hair. That’s safe.
She stood again, faced the mirror, and pulled her hair into a messy bun, then unpinned it and ran her fingers through the knots. Then twisted it again. Then undid it. Tried a braid. Undid that, too. Every attempt made her scowl deeper. Nothing looked right.
The room around her looked like a boutique exploded. Clothes on the floor, shoes scattered underfoot, makeup open and untouched. She stood in front of the mirror, chest rising and falling a little too fast, arms crossed over her bare abdomen.
Then a thought barged into her head, uninvited and set to music: Half-dressed, apologetic. A mess, she looked pathetic. The Hamilton lyric made her groan aloud.
“Focus, Gem.” She rubbed her face, then planted both hands on her thighs.
Come on. It’s not a fashion show. It’s just Pearl.
But her stomach twisted anyway.
She sat there for a long beat, heart thudding just a little too loud. A slow exhale rolled through her, cooling the heat rising in her chest.
Then—quietly, almost like a grounding whisper to herself—“You don’t need to be perfect. You’ve made it this far with her. Stop overthinking it. Just... make it yours.”
She let the words hang in the room. Just for her.
Her gaze drifted toward the side of the closet she barely touched. Fingers brushing the fabric, she pulled out a long, soft dress in a shade of green that reminded her of early spring. It was pleated, subtle, the back dipped lower than she usually dared, but something about it felt... right.
She slipped it on. The hem swirled just around her calves. Her arms felt exposed, skin almost too bare in the fading light. She shivered once. But then she took a breath. And another. She could work with this.
She added her favorite gold earrings, and a little swipe of mascara. Nothing else. She didn’t need it tonight.
Her hands were still shaking a little as she pinned her hair into a loose bun, pinning it with the little floral clip Pearl had once complimented. She spritzed a small cloud of perfume at the base of her neck, the scent soft and warm, then stepped back.
The girl in the mirror looked... like herself. Not someone else’s idea. Not a Pinterest board. Just her.
Gem tilted her head. Smiled.
She touched the edge of the mirror with one finger, eyes tracing her own reflection like she was still getting used to it.
“Okay,” she whispered to her reflection. “Yeah. That’s me.”
Pearl stepped into her old bedroom—the one that had quietly transformed into their shared workspace ever since she started sleeping with Gem every night—and shut the door gently behind her. It still smelled faintly of the lavender Gem had potted by the window and printer ink, soft and sterile. The desk was already set up, her makeup laid out with the precision of a chemistry lab: foundation, eyeliner, brow pencil, gloss. She stood in front of it for a moment, breathing shallowly. Her fingers were steady. Her throat wasn’t.
She’d chosen her colors already—crimson, white, black. Bold. Controlled. Clean. But the outfit itself... she hadn’t decided.
She started with the wrap dress. A rich, silky red that complimented her skin tone in a way she usually only allowed herself to notice in private. It slid over her hips easily, the neckline dipping to frame her collarbones just right. The fabric hugged her in a way that felt intentional , even flattering. She’d even chosen the jewelry already: a delicate moon-shaped pendant she loved too much to wear casually. She clipped it around her neck and exhaled at the faint sting of cold metal
But when she turned slightly toward the mirror, the soft curve of fabric at her hip shifted—and the bulge beneath it caught her eye.
Her lungs tightened like someone had pulled a string around her ribcage. Her stomach turned.
They’ll stare. They’ll notice. She’ll… notice.
Her hands trembled as she reached for the zipper. The dress came off fast. She tossed it onto the bed and turned away from the mirror before her eyes could sting. Her breath came in uneven pulls. She refused to cry. Not tonight.
She tried a pantsuit next. She went through the motions like muscle memory: black slacks, crisp button-up, binder flattened tight against her chest. When she looked up again, her reflection was clean. And sharp. And… unfamiliar.
There was some relief in the compression, at first—relief in the way the fabric pressed her into something smaller, flatter. More manageable.
But her chest ached. Her boobs fought the binder. And her face—flushed, glossy from makeup—looked wrong on top of the outfit. Too feminine. Not enough. Some awful in-between.
Pick a lane, Pearl. Jesus.
She sat down hard in her desk chair, binder compressing her ribs with every breath. She stared at herself for too long. Pale. Perfectly still. Her hands were shaking.
They told me I could be anything, she thought bitterly. So why do I still feel like nothing?
There’s no winning. I’m always too much of one thing and not enough of the other.
Her shoulders slumped, head tipping back. The ceiling was just the ceiling, blank and impassive.
She exhaled. Not sharply—just a slow, intentional breath that steadied the storm.
What if I stop trying to win?
She stood again, slower this time. Her eyes flicked toward the last thing she'd considered: a clean white blouse with a deep neckline—just enough cleavage to be bold, not apologetic. She paired it with the black slacks again. Added a wide belt to cinch her waist, then layered the crimson overcoat over top.
Her chest still rose and fell a little fast. But she put it all on anyway.
She dressed quickly, with something resembling confidence. The sleeves needed adjusting. The neckline sat just off-center. She fixed it, then took one full step back.
The outfit wasn’t perfect. But it was hers.
She turned toward the mirror. The ponytail came together clean and sharp, tied high. Her eyeliner followed the curve of her lashes like a blade—steady, symmetrical. She added blush, not too much. Just enough to make her look a little more alive.
It was a mask. But it was her mask.
She stepped back for a final look and stared at her reflection, long enough that the details stopped mattering. For once, she didn’t flinch.
Her expression started neutral, as it always did. Then softened, just slightly.
She tilted her head. “Yeah. That’s me. That’ll do.”
Gem stepped out of the bedroom at the same time Pearl emerged from the other end of the hallway. They both froze mid-step, like they’d crashed into something invisible.
The light in the apartment had shifted—the soft gold of early evening now giving way to a deeper, diffused warmth from the floor lamp near the couch. It made everything glow.
Gem’s breath hitched. Her hand lifted reflexively toward her hair, as if to adjust something—then faltered, forgotten halfway through. She stared.
“Whoa,” she whispered.
Pearl’s jaw tightened at first, lips parting like she meant to say something clever, but her eyes had already swept over Gem’s figure—green dress, loose bun, gold jewelry caught in the warm light—and whatever words she had prepared promptly vanished.
“You—” she started, voice caught halfway between awe and disbelief. Nothing else came out.
They both blinked, looked away for a heartbeat, then tried to speak at the same time—stumbling over overlapping syllables. Gem laughed first, light and breathy, rubbing the back of her neck.
“You look…” she hesitated, then tried again with more sincerity, “You look incredible.”
Pearl’s lips curved slowly. She lifted her chin just a touch, recovering her composure as if slipping on a second coat.
“I was about to say the same to you,” she replied, smooth but quiet.
The compliment landed between them with more weight than either had expected—something soft and reverent underneath the flirt. Not just admiration, but the kind that slowed time down. They held each other’s gaze for one long second too many, neither daring to move, until finally they both looked away again.
Gem’s fingers curled briefly at her sides, as if fighting the urge to reach out. She was smiling now—wide and warm and stunned. This is really happening.
Pearl felt heat rise to her cheeks, but this time she didn’t retreat behind her sleeve. She let the blush bloom, let it be seen. She looked back at Gem and held her gaze.
Gem cocked an eyebrow and gave a playful spin, the soft green fabric of her dress fluttering around her calves. She stopped with a grin and planted one hand on her hip. “Well? What do you think?”
Pearl’s eyes followed every line of movement, a soft exhale catching in her throat. She tilted her head slightly, stepping in just close enough to make the air between them shift. “I think…”
Her voice faltered for a beat, lips parting as if she’d forgotten the next word. Then, in a quieter, steadier tone, she finished, “…that I’m the luckiest woman alive.”
Gem laughed, the sound light but a little uneven. God, don’t melt now. “Flattered,” she said, grinning.
Pearl smiled, a low chuckle slipping out before she reached up slowly and brushed a fingertip over Gem’s shoulder under the guise of dusting off an invisible smudge. Her touch was light, reverent, but deliberate. She let it linger for just a second longer than necessary. Just long enough to feel the warmth of her skin.
Gem didn’t move away. If anything, she leaned in—barely, instinctively.
As the apartment door clicked shut behind them, a crisp breath of night air wrapped around their ankles. It was cool, but not sharp—just enough to paint their cheeks pink and draw a breath from both of them.
Gem turned with theatrical flair and offered her arm in an exaggerated bow. “Shall we, m’lady?”
Pearl rolled her eyes, but the smile tugging at her lips betrayed her. She took the offered arm with practiced elegance. “God, you’re insufferable.”
“And yet, here you are,” Gem said, letting their elbows bump as they descended the steps.
Pearl didn’t argue.
The wind tugged at the hem of their coats. For once, Gem had dressed properly for the weather—her long, forest-green coat looking uncharacteristically elegant, like something that had been forgotten in the back of her closet and only just remembered. Pearl spared it a quick glance, noting the structured collar, the way it framed Gem’s shoulders. She really tried.
Pearl hummed, pulling out her phone to call the ride. While she tapped through the app, she leaned slightly into Gem’s side—not enough to be obvious, but enough to feel the warmth seeping through Gem’s coat.
Pearl’s phone buzzed. “Driver’s two minutes out.”
They lingered near the curb, streetlight painting their shadows across the sidewalk. Their breath mingled in faint white puffs. A pause stretched between them—not awkward, just full of anticipation.
Gem leaned in, voice dropping just enough to stir warmth against the shell of Pearl’s ear. “You’ve left a lot to the imagination tonight.”
Pearl’s brow lifted, lips curving. “You’re just mad I outdressed you.”
Gem gasped with mock offense. “Excuse you? I’m wearing heels.”
“I noticed,” Pearl said dryly, her smirk deepening.
The rideshare pulled up beside them, headlights cutting briefly through the fogged quiet. They slid into the backseat without a word, shoulders brushing as they settled in. Neither of them moved to create space.
The city passed in blurs—neon signs reflected in puddles, distant conversations on the sidewalks, a buzz of nightlife filtering through the closed windows. But inside the car, everything felt muted. Safe. Warm.
Pearl tilted her head, eyes out the window as she spoke. “The place I picked… it’s a little ways off campus. But it looks really good. Traditional. You’re gonna love it.”
Gem smiled, watching her. “You sound confident.”
Pearl smiled and turned to look at her, eyes shining. For a moment, Gem caught the faintest trace of her perfume—something soft and grounded, like sandalwood and something floral she couldn’t name. It made something in her stomach flip.
Gem chuckled, the sound low, a little tired and a little content. Pearl noticed that tone—how it always softened when Gem was happy. It made her chest ache in the best way.
Their hands stayed in their laps. Their legs only touched when the car turned. But those small touches felt like more than enough—intentional, present, seen . Neither of them said anything about it, but the weight of the moment hung between them like silk.
The rest of the ride passed in teasing, quiet smiles, soft remarks that faded into silence again. Beneath all of it was a slow, steady thrum— a growing awareness , not of what would happen next, but of everything that already was. The brush of coat sleeves. The ghost of Pearl’s touch from earlier. The memory of Gem’s bare shoulders catching the light in the hallway.
Neither of them said it aloud, but they were thinking the same thing:
I don’t want this to end.
At one point, their eyes met briefly in the window’s reflection—faint silhouettes on dark glass, close and soft and unsaid.