Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2025-11-04
Words:
1,313
Chapters:
1/1
Comments:
3
Kudos:
170
Bookmarks:
20
Hits:
1,019

Gay Halloween

Summary:

A Buddie SMAU

Chris points out that there's a common theme in Eddie's past Halloween costumes

Notes:

This was originally posted over on Bluesky: Gay Halloween | A Buddie SMAU

Make sure you have Show Creator's Style turned on! You'll still be able to read it if you have it turned off, but the formatting won't be nearly as nice 😁

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

1. Chris texts Eddie with a question.

Chris

Today

Chris
my friends are online now
Eddie
Is your homework done?
Chris
it will be
Eddie
No video games until it's done.
Chris
k
what are you going as for halloween this year
Eddie
I’m not sure yet. Why?
Chris
wondering if you were planning on continuing with your theme
Eddie
I wasn’t aware I had a theme…?
Chris
oh you have a theme
Eddie
All right, then. What’s my theme?
Chris
what do all the following things have in common
exhibit 1
exhibit 2
exhibit 3
Eddie
Where are you even finding these?
And why do they all have that filter?
Chris
all will become clear
exhibit 4
exhibit 5
exhibit 6
Eddie
Okay, that one’s not even a Halloween costume.
Chris
but it helps prove my point so
do you see the theme yet
Eddie
Absolutely not.
Chris
well i think this last one really pulls it all together
Eddie
???
I’m confused.
Chris
Eddie
Chris.
Are you trying to tell me something?
Chris
ALL YOUR HALLOWEEN COSTUMES ARE GAY
Eddie
First: It’s not nice to yell at people, even over text.
Second: I’m pretty sure it’s not okay to call things gay.
Chris
🙄
thats only if youre using it as an insult
its okay if its true
Eddie
I wear normal Halloween costumes.
Chris
normal gay halloween costumes
Eddie
How are any of those gay?
Chris
you want the list?
okay
1 - youre literally obsessed with the guy in that movie, like OBSESSED
2 - this one has a muscle suit
3 - i dont want to get grounded so i wont say it
4 - i mean... youve watched these movies. very gay
5 - werewolves are literally queer coded
6 - aliens. probes. need i go on
7 - i think this one speaks for itself
Eddie
All right, that's enough.

2. Eddie seeks out a second opinion from Hen.

Hen

Today

Eddie
Do you think I wear gay Halloween costumes?
Hen
Good morning to you, too
Eddie
I'm serious.
Chris thinks I do.
Hen
Okay
How do I put this
Hold on, I need to consult my advisor
Hen
My official statement is: No comment
Eddie
Great.
Thanks.
Hen
You're so welcome
Hen
Sorry, I have to ask
Is this about the werewolf costume?
Eddie
Et tu, Brute?

3. Eddie has a costume idea.

Chris

Today

Eddie
What if I go as a cowboy?
That's not gay.
Chris
um
sorry trying to figure out how going as the cowboy from brokeback mountain is somehow not gay
Eddie
Okay, the existence of Brokeback Mountain does not make all cowboys gay.
Chris
you just don't get it
Eddie
Buck was a cowboy last year, and he's not gay. He's bi.
Chris
mmm
kind of feels like youre proving my point
Eddie
How's that homework going?

4. Eddie needs Buck's help.

Buck

Today

Eddie
Buck.
Buck
Eddie
Buck
Do you have a question
Or did you just want to say my name
Eddie
I need help.
Buck
Ok
Eddie
What would you say makes a Halloween costume gay?
Buck
Um
Huh
Not what I was expecting
I guess like... sexy costumes are pretty gay??
Or dressing up as a gay character
Idk
Why?
Eddie
So if you saw a guy dressed up sexy for Halloween, you would assume he was gay?
Buck
I wouldn't ASSUME
He might be bi
Or he just spends a lot of time in the gym
But yeah, gay would come to mind
And again... why??
Eddie
I'm going to send you some pictures, and I need you to tell me how gay they are on a scale of 0-10.
Objectively.
Buck
This is a weird game.
Eddie
So you're in?
Buck
Obviously
Eddie
First one.
Buck
3, I guess
Eddie
Really?
I thought that one would get at least a 6.
Buck
Meh, lacks creativity
Eddie
Okay, what about this one?
Buck
Ooo
9
Eddie
Sorry
What?
Buck
They look very strong
And capable
😏
Also, werewolves are very queer coded, so that ups the gay score
Eddie
Did Chris tell you to say that?
Buck
Huh?
Eddie
Never mind.
Well, I was trying to establish a baseline, but clearly I don't understand your taste in men.
Maybe this is stupid.
Buck
No, I'm getting into it now! What's the next one?

5. Back to Chris.

Chris

Today

Eddie
Can you send me those photos you found of my costumes?
Chris
with or without the gay pride overlay
Eddie
The what?
I thought the gay pride flag was rainbow.
Chris
you have so much to learn
Eddie
All right, enough with the snark.
Send me the photos and I'll let you stay up an extra hour all weekend.
Chris
hour and a half
Eddie
One hour. And I won't ask you about homework until Sunday night.
Chris
deal

6. Eddie has a few more costumes for Buck to rate.

Buck

Today

Eddie
Buck
Is this a trick question
Eddie
Why?
Buck
Because that one's you
Eddie
Just rate it.
Buck
10
Eddie
Really?
Buck
What? Kurt Russell is really hot in those movies
Eddie
Okay. This one?
Buck
Is that a muscle suit?
Eddie
Possibly.
Buck
Umm 8
Eddie
EIGHT??
Buck
Oh, is this suddenly not a safe space anymore?
Eddie
You think you know someone...
Buck
Fuck off
What's the next one?
Eddie
Buck
Oh
My
God
Is this one you too?!?
Eddie
Rating first.
Buck
9
Eddie
I don't feel like you're taking this seriously.
Buck
Eddie, I would never joke about Andy Samberg.
Eddie
You're the worst person I know.
Buck
Now this one I know is you
10
Eddie
Buck
10
Smash
Eddie
🖕
Buck
I literally took this picture
10
Eddie
Eddie
...Buck?

7. Buck texts Maddie.

Maddie

Today

Buck
HELP
SOS
EMERGENCY
911
Maddie
911. What's the cause of your overreaction?
Buck
So Eddie
Maddie
Oh boy
Buck
He started texting me pictures of Halloween costumes and asking me to rate them on a scale of 0 to gay.
Maddie
Wow. You finally did it
Buck
DID WHAT
Maddie
You managed to surprise me
So what caused the panic spiral
Buck
He started sending me pictures of his Halloween costumes
Maddie
...
Okay, I'll bite. What did you rate them?
Buck
8
9
Mostly 10s
WHAT ELSE WAS I SUPPOSED TO DO
HE LOOKS HOT IN EVERYTHING AND MY FEELINGS FOR HIM ARE VERY GAY
Maddie
Okay
First things first
Let's take a breath

8. Eddie talks to Chris.

Chris

Today

Eddie
How did you know?
Chris
know what
Eddie
That I'm gay?
Chris
youre gay?
this is my shocked face
😐
Eddie
Okay, pause. I think we should talk about this in person, not just over text.

9. Buck finally replies to Eddie.

Buck

Today

Eddie
Buck
Sorry
Had to handle a family emergency
Not an emergency
Everyone's fine
Especially me
I'm fine
Sorry
I'm going to rate the costume now
I think it's a 5
Right?
Because half of the people in the picture like guys
Haha
Get it?
...Eddie?

10. Eddie has decided on his next costume.

Buck

Today

Eddie
You rated it wrong.
Buck
What?
Eddie
But that's okay. I think I figured out my Halloween costume.
Buck
Was that what this was about?
Eddie
No. This was about Chris thinking all my Halloween costumes are gay.
Buck
???
Eddie
Guess he was right, going by your scores.
Anyway, want to see my costume for this year?
Buck
Obviously
Eddie
Buck
You're going as yourself??
Eddie
I figured I should stick with my theme.
Buck
Your theme?
Eddie
Of gay Halloween costumes.
Buck
Eddie
EDDie
EDDIE
Did you just
Did you just come out to me over text
VIA HALLOWEEN COSTUME?!?
Eddie
Unless you'd rather do another couples costume?
Buck
KDOALKDJDKSLKAHAHD KLDLFKDHSAKSLLDFLD
EDDIE
WHAT THE AHDLFUCK
I'm coming over
Kshsmdllss
Stay right there
Eddie
Not going anywhere, Buck.
💖

Notes:

You can find me on Bluesky or on Twitter.