Work Text:
In all the chaos of quests, schoolwork, and demigod drama, Percy and Annabeth had grown used to stolen moments—quick kisses behind cabins at Camp Half-Blood, hands intertwined under the table at lunch, secret smiles traded across crowded rooms. Privacy was a luxury they almost never had. Between monster attacks and mortal responsibilities, it was easy to forget what normal felt like.
Sally Jackson’s apartment was filled with the scent of freshly baked blue cookies and the muffled hum of city life drifting through the windows. Sally emerged from her room, fastening an earring, her eyes sparkling with affection as she found Percy and Annabeth standing together near the kitchen counter, “Paul and I are heading out for a much-needed date night,” she announced handing Percy a twenty for pizza, “Order whatever you want and there are fresh cookies on the counter so help yourselves. I’ll text before we’re home.”
Percy grinned, pocketing the bill, “Thanks, Mom.”
Annabeth tucked a stray curl behind her ear, returning Sally’s warm smile, “Thank you, Sally. Have a great night.”
Sally winked at them both, lingering a moment in the doorway, “We will. Enjoy your night being ordinary teenagers,” she said, her voice full of good-natured teasing.
With a final wave, she slipped out, her laughter and the click of the door fading into the hallway. The apartment seemed bigger, quieter, without her presence—a gentle, unfamiliar hush settling over the space. Percy and Annabeth stood in the kitchen for a moment longer, letting the reality of being alone sink in.
Percy stretched, rolling his shoulders and reaching for his phone, “So, pizza first or cookies?”
Annabeth nudged his leg with hers, a mischievous glint in her eyes, “I know you. You want the cookies.”
“Wow you didn’t have to call me out like that, Wise Girl,” Percy teased, already snatching the plate Sally had left out, blue chocolate chip and still warm, and brought it to the coffee table. Annabeth settled onto the couch, pulling her knees up and patting the spot beside her. Percy dropped down next to her, handing her a cookie and snagging one for himself.
Annabeth accepted the cookie, her fingers brushing his just a little longer than necessary. She smiled, breaking off a piece and popping it in her mouth, “So, what cinematic masterpiece are you subjecting me to tonight?”
Percy grinned, reaching for the remote, “I’ll have you know, my taste is impeccable.”
She gave him a skeptical look, “Sharknado is far from a cult classic Seaweed Brain.”
Percy gasped in mock offense, clutching his chest, “Sharknado is a work of art! You just don’t appreciate flying sharks.”
Annabeth giggled, nudging him with her shoulder, “I appreciate good storytelling and, you know, movies that obey the laws of physics.”
Percy waggled his eyebrows, “Where’s the fun in that?”
She rolled her eyes but couldn’t hide her smile, taking another bite of her cookie, “How about I pick the movie, and you pick the pizza?"
Percy pretended to mull it over, tapping his chin with exaggerated seriousness, “Hmm, so you get full creative control over the movie, and I get to unleash my wild pizza preferences? Dangerous territory, Wise Girl.”
Annabeth raised an eyebrow, smirking, “I’ll take my chances. As long as you don’t order anchovies.”
Percy grinned, pulling up the pizza app on his phone, “No anchovies. Got it. But I’m adding extra cheese, pepperoni, and maybe some pineapple cause life is short.”
Annabeth scoffed, “You wouldn’t dare.”
He leaned in, voice conspiratorial, “Try me.”
Annabeth shook her head, but her expression was soft, eyes bright as she scrolled through the movie options, “You’re lucky I love you.”
Percy glanced over, catching the way her lips curved in a half-hidden smile. He felt a familiar warmth spread through him—the kind that only came from nights like this, when everything felt simple, sweet, and safe.
As the evening slipped by, the apartment took on the easy, golden glow of comfort. The scent of buttery popcorn and cheesy pizza mingled in the air, and the fizz of soda punctuated their laughter. Percy and Annabeth had abandoned any sense of personal space, sprawled together across the couch with their legs intertwined. The coffee table was cluttered with pizza crusts and soda cans, and a bowl of popcorn rested between them.
“So,” Percy began, tossing a piece of popcorn into his mouth, “If I asked you to storm the castle with me, would you?”
Annabeth gave him a sidelong look, lips curving into a playful smile, “Depends. Are you planning to scale the Cliffs of Insanity or duel a six-fingered man first?”
Percy grinned, reaching for her hand, “I was hoping you’d handle the clever plans and leave the sword fighting to me.”
Annabeth squeezed his fingers, her eyes dancing, “So I get to be the brains and you get to be the reckless hero?”
Percy bumped her knee with his, feigning indignation, “Hey, reckless heroes get all the best lines.”
Annabeth laughed, eyes sparkling, “And sometimes they get popcorn thrown at them.” She grabbed a handful and tossed it at his chest, scattering kernels everywhere.
Percy gasped in mock outrage, lunging for her, “Oh, you’re asking for it now!”
Percy, don’t you dare,” Annabeth shrieked, doubling over with laughter as Percy launched his tickle attack, fingers darting for her sides. She tried to squirm away, giggling uncontrollably, but he was relentless, both of them twisting and writhing in a flurry of popcorn and laughter.
They rolled, tangled together in their playful battle, until gravity claimed them both—sending them tumbling off the couch in a heap. Percy landed on top of Annabeth, their laughter dissolving into breathless silence. For a moment, they just lay there, faces inches apart, the world narrowing down to the golden lamplight and the sound of their quickened breaths.
Annabeth’s curls fanned out across the rug, her cheeks flushed, lips parted as she looked up at him. Percy braced himself above her, hands planted on either side of her shoulders, heart pounding, eyes locked onto hers as the hush between them thickened. Her fingers curled into his shirt collar, tugging him down with a fierce sort of determination. Their lips met in a kiss that was soft for a heartbeat—sweet, lingering, full of all the warmth and laughter that had filled the room moments before.
Then, as if something in both of them snapped, the kiss deepened. Percy’s hand slid to Annabeth’s waist, pulling her closer, while her fingers tightened in Percy’s shirt, holding him close as the kiss grew more intense—clumsy at first, uncertain in its newness, but quickly desperate and hungry as they found a rhythm together. Percy was acutely aware of the press of her body against his, the way her breath hitched every time his hand skimmed her waist, the softness of her lips as she kissed him back with equal fervor.
It was dizzying, the way everything seemed to blur: the forgotten movie flickering shadows on the wall, the popcorn scattered across the rug, the whole world shrinking down to the heat between them. Percy’s heart thundered in his chest, every sense tuned to Annabeth—her taste, her scent, the way she trembled ever so slightly beneath his touch. The kiss dragged on, deepening and softening in turns, both of them exploring, learning, giving in to the rush of feeling that neither had dared to voice before.
Annabeth’s hands traveled from his collar to his shoulders, then up into his hair, her fingers winding through the dark curls and tugging just enough to make him groan—a low, unguarded sound that sent a shiver through both of them. His eyes fluttered open, dark and shining in the lamplight, and he gazed down at her with an intensity that made her pulse race.
The heat between them was overwhelming, all hesitation forgotten. Percy was lost in Annabeth—her flushed cheeks, her parted, swollen lips, the way she looked at him like he was the only thing in the world. His hand moved with instinct, sliding up her side and over her shirt, cupping her breast without a second thought. Annabeth gasped, a soft moan escaping her lips as she pressed herself into his hand, her body arching for more. The sound sent Percy spiraling, and he kissed her harder, desperate to taste every bit of her. Annabeth’s fingers tightened in his hair, her breath coming fast, matching the frantic beat of his heart.
Suddenly, the quiet was shattered by the unmistakable rattle of a key in the lock. Both of them froze, eyes wide in panic, hearts pounding for a completely different reason now. The front door began to swing open—Sally and Paul were back.
In a frantic rush, Percy tumbled off Annabeth, almost tripping over the edge of the rug as he scrambled to his feet. Annabeth quickly smoothed out her shirt and tried to tame her wild curls. Percy snatched up the popcorn bowl and plopped down beside her on the couch, leaving a careful gap between them.
Sally paused in the entryway, her gaze flicking over the scene—the scattered popcorn on the floor, the movie playing a bit too loudly, and the two teenagers sitting stiffly on the couch, faces flushed and eyes fixed straight ahead. Paul stepped in just behind her, raising his eyebrows at the mess but saying nothing, a small smile playing at the corners of his mouth.
A faint smile tugged at her lips, “Seems like you both had a fun night,” she replied, a hint of amusement in her voice.
Percy glanced up at Sally, his face still tinged with color, “Yeah! Uh—super fun,” he stammered, his voice pitching a little higher than usual. He tried to muster a casual smile, but it came out more sheepish than confident.
Sally’s eyes lingered on them for a moment, her smile widening just a touch—amused, gentle, but far from oblivious. She arched an eyebrow, clearly picking up on the tension and the way both teens seemed to be trying just a bit too hard to look innocent.
“Mm-hmm,” Sally said, her tone knowing, “Glad you enjoyed yourselves.”
Annabeth, cheeks still pink and curls a little wild, quickly set the popcorn bowl aside and cleared her throat, “I should probably head back,” she said, voice steadier than she felt.
Paul, leaning in the doorway with a gentle smile, added, “You sure you don’t need a ride?”
Annabeth shook her head, shouldering her bag, “I should be okay.”
Sally nodded, her eyes soft but still sparkling with quiet amusement, “Just let us know when you get back, okay?”
Annabeth smiled gratefully, glancing from Sally to Paul, “I will thanks.”
Percy stood, still looking a little flustered but determined to play it cool, “I’ll walk you out,” he said, offering Annabeth a reassuring smile.
They slipped out into the hallway, the door closing behind them, the sounds of the apartment faded, replaced by the quiet hush of the hallway.
“Well that was…something,” Percy exhales.
Annabeth let out a quiet laugh, her nerves finally giving way to amusement, “Yeah, not exactly how I pictured the night ending.” They stopped near the elevator, she turned to face him. Her eyes shone, full of warmth and mischief. “But I wouldn’t mind if it happened again,” she admitted, voice low.
Percy’s smile grew, the nervousness fading into something gentler, more certain, “Me neither.”
“I’ll text you when I’m back,” she reassures as she steps closer, her hand squeezing his one last time.
Percy nods, his grin widening, “I’ll be waiting.”
Annabeth gives him a soft, lingering look—a promise in her eyes—before she turns and steps into the elevator. As the doors begin to close, she glances back at Percy, her smile playful and sweet.
“Good night, Seaweed Brain,” she calls softly.
Percy chuckles, warmth blooming in his chest, “Good night, Wise Girl.”
The elevator doors slide shut. Percy walked back into the apartment, the stupid grin still plastered on his face. He barely made it past the threshold before Sally appeared in the hallway, arms crossed, a soft smile on her lips.
She waited until he got closer, then spoke quietly, “You know, you don’t have to pretend with me, Percy. I was young once too.”
Percy’s cheeks reddened, but he kept smiling, shrugging a little, “I know, Mom.”
Sally stepped closer, her gaze gentle, “I know how much you and Annabeth care about each other,” she began, voice quiet and sincere, “Just remember being close to someone means being respectful and safe, always and if you ever need to talk—about anything—I’m here, okay?”
Percy met her eyes, the embarrassment fading into gratitude, “Thanks, Mom.”
She smiled, squeezing his shoulder, “Of course, now don’t forget to clean up that popcorn.”
Percy laughed, the tension gone, and headed toward the living room, feeling lighter than ever.