1 - 20 of 76 Bookmarked Items in Red Dead Redemption 2 Fanfics
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
So Shines a Good Deed in a Weary World by C_Montgomery_Burns
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), Red Dead
23 May 2025
Tags
Summary
Molly feels she has been all but forgotten by Dutch. Who would have thought Arthur Morgan would be the one to lift her spirits?
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
A Cardinal fish says, "God is dead" The whale says, "Get out of my head" by DeanWinchesterIsBabyGirlCoded
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
01 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
There's a fire in Arthurs' soul and he's not sure who lit it. It lies just below the surface, crackling and roaring, scathing anyone who gets too close. He tried at one point to put the fire out, to hide the flaming spilling out from the cracks in his foundation, but it never brought him an ounce of good or a hint of deliverance.
Or, Arthur is flooded with guilt and self hatred, Charles finds him and helps him feel better.
Arthur is very out of it in this so he might seem ooc but I tried my best to stay accurate while depicting what he's going through idk
Idk what this is and I'm bad at summaries but I tried my best
┐('～`;)┌-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
death is just so full and man so small by achilleanscribe
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
12 Mar 2022
Tags
Summary
The two people closest to Eagle Flies mourn his death together.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
The Taller the Tree, the Farther the Fall by Zana_Zira
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
18 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
"'Y'know, for such a 'mighty warrior,' you sure do whine a lot. You'll be fine. It can't hurt nearly as much as breaking it in the first place; at least setting it won't require falling out of a tree.'
Eagle Flies winced as Rains Fall's eyebrows nearly jumped up into his hairline. Damn it, Paytah...
'Falling out of a tree? What in the world were you doing to fall out of a tree?' He shook his head, a long-suffering sigh escaping his lips. 'Never mind. I'm not sure I want to know.'"
As usual, Eagle Flies makes an attempt at heroism. And as usual, it goes awry, leaving his father and his best friend to patch him up afterward. Thankfully, they don't seem to mind (too much).
Series
- Part 4 of Tumblr Ask Box Fics
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
Tags
Summary
I was a girl - until your call
Commanded me to cross the sea
I've nothing left, I gave you all...-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
Arthur Morgan died in 1899 after being betrayed by his supposed father figure and saving John Marston and his family. For his honorable road in life, he was sent back in time to the beginning of Red Dead Redemption 2. Knowing who Dutch really is, Arthur, free from TB, sets out on a journey to save as many people as he could, and perhaps even gain something new along the way...
This is my reasoning to write time traveling Arthur. I'm surprised by the lack of him time traveling fics. Taking him from Chapter 6 to Chapter 1 or even 2 presents so many opportunities. You have an Arthur who broke free of his indoctrination to Dutch and has been humbled by TB and blind loyalty. You take him to the beginning of the end, and you have a very good concept. Additionally, I feel like too many fics are too nice to Dutch. He has to take personal responsibility for Blackwater and all of the fuck ups that he'd made, something I doubt he would. He is extremely egoistical. He’s always right no matter what. That’s why he views the people who question his "morals" (or lack thereof) as “traitors” (Arthur and John) and people who follow him blindly as “loyal” (Micah, Bill, and Javier).
Series
- Part 1 of Time Travel In The West
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 135,745
- Chapters:
- 50/50
- Collections:
- 2
- Comments:
- 371
- Kudos:
- 1,529
- Bookmarks:
- 301
- Hits:
- 71,827
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
Enter, Pursued By Defeat by PurpleArrowzandLeather
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
18 Oct 2026
Tags
Summary
John dies in front of his barn. He's happy enough to find out Arthur is waiting for him on the other side. However, what happens when forces beyond their control tear John from the afterlife and throw him twelve years into the past? One thing is for certain; John is going to save his brother.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 279,481
- Chapters:
- 72/80
- Comments:
- 718
- Kudos:
- 2,410
- Bookmarks:
- 587
- Hits:
- 116,029
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
Tags
Summary
Jack Marston is a writer publishing nothing but potboilers under another man's name. He's been trying but nothing has yet to stick. When an old friend comes knocking, however, it throws Jack out of his routine and may just be enough to give him the push he needs.
or
Jack Marston from 1911-1921.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
Arthur had never believed in stories of sea creatures - not until he saw one with his very own eyes.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
The Man Who Told Everything by MelancholyMusez
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
28 Jan 2024
Tags
Summary
John Marston thought he knew everything, but when he starts seeing an older Jack in his dreams, he realizes that maybe he knows nothing.
Even before he had a run-in with the wolves in Colter, John Marston grew up knowing death was always near. So what happens when after his fight with the wolves in the mountains, he starts seeing things—an older Jack and a familiar strange man—who keep telling him cryptic things about the fate of the gang? Telling him that if things don’t change… then maybe he isn’t the only one who is doomed.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
tell me how it's like far out at sea by besselfcn
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
27 Sep 2019
Tags
Summary
John doesn't know how to sleep anymore. He doesn't know how to look at Abigail anymore.
He put that awful look in her eye. He gave her something the world could take away from her and he ought to have known it’d do it.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
For a brief second they had locked eyes; Dutch watching him as he lay sprawled along the bank, gasping for breath. In the distance, the silhouettes of the army men were approaching, the commands shouted as the thunderous hooves neared.
And Dutch had left him there.
The man hadn’t even looked back.
_____________________________________
Whumptober 2020
Prompt #1: Let's Hang Out Sometime 'Shackled'
Prompt#5: Where Do You Think You're Going? 'Failed Escape'
Prompt#12: I Think I've Broken Something 'Broken Trust'
Prompt#19 'Broken Hearts 'Greif'Series
- Part 9 of Whumptober 2020
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 3,370
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 8
- Kudos:
- 164
- Bookmarks:
- 25
- Hits:
- 2,048
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
Tags
Summary
1. Ring: The journey of the ring Arthur gave to Mary
2. Mindless: The final moments of Javier Escuella
3. Bait: Kieran helps Sean catch a couple of bandits.
4. Freeze: John's not so final moments on the mountain.
5. Build: Dutch was never much of a builder
6. Husky: The sound of John Marston
7. Enchanted: The tale of Hosea and his love
8. Frail: That's the way it is.
9. Pattern: Tilly always had quick hands.
10. Snow: Arthur takes Charles fishing.
11. Jack visits an old friend.
12. Only the good die young.-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
Soft footsteps crunched on the rocks behind you, and you slumped deeper into your thick jacket, hot silent tears rolling down your cheeks.
“Oh, Charles,” you said softly, your voice breaking as he crouched next to you. “Look how they left him.”
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
After an embarrassing incident, Charles turns to the only person he knows won't mock him...too much.
My contribution to the Ride With Me Charthur Fanzine
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
Charles and Arthur sit by Flat Iron Lake and talk about whittling and drawing
--
:Excerpt:
“I didn’t know you drew like that,” Charles said, locked on the journal.
Arthur rubbed the back of his reddened neck, hand unsure if he should cover what Charles had already seen. He caught himself between a laugh and scoff, incredulous. “Ain’t nothin’ much, jus’ somethin’ I like to do.”
Charles stared at him. “Strong words for a talent like that.”
The nape of Arthur’s neck grew redder, a fluster escaping his mouth, stuttering. Charles felt a squeeze in his chest.
“…thank you."
Series
- Part 1 of It's the God Heroin Prays to
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
Tags
Summary
charles fusses over javier
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
Javier left camp on a job that should have taken as long as it did. Charles remained at camp, worrying for his lover.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
Charles gets upset when you and Arthur stay out in the cold too long. The blizzard isn't letting up anytime soon, so you find a better way to stay warm.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-
-
Tags
Summary
Based on this request: Can I get Charles catching the reader drawing him? I feel like it’d be so cute to see him all bashful n embarrassed that someone finds him attractive enough to make art of.
-
Bookmark Collections:
-