Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club
Series Metadata
Listing Series
-
CLAUDIA by Marguerlucy
Fandoms: Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Series - Alvin Schwartz, Baby-Sitters Club - Ann M. Martin
27 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
A mash-up of "Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark" and "The Baby-Sitters Club."
When Claudia Kishi makes the most insane looking entry in the Stonybrook Scarecrow Contest, Alan and Trevor laugh it off. But ScareClaudia will be the only one left laughing at the end.
Disclaimer: the first few stories in this series use direct text from the Schwartz versions, but at reader request, I've stopped this habit as of Jessi's story.
Series
- Part 1 of Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club
-
The Hook Brings Mary Anne Back by Marguerlucy
Fandoms: Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Series - Alvin Schwartz, Baby-Sitters Club - Ann M. Martin
28 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
What if The Baby-Sitters Club mashed up with the Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark universe?
Logan takes Mary Anne out to Stoneybrook's "Lovers Point," but he's not about to get the hand-stuff he's expecting.
Disclaimer: the first few stories in this series use direct text from the Schwartz versions, but at reader request, I've stopped this habit as of Jessi's story.
Series
- Part 2 of Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club
-
The Actual Ghost at Dawn's House by Marguerlucy
Fandoms: Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Series - Alvin Schwartz, Baby-Sitters Club - Ann M. Martin
29 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Dawn Schafer is certain her house is haunted. Can she put the spirit to rest?
Disclaimer: the first few stories in this series use direct text from the Schwartz versions, but at reader request, I've stopped this habit as of Jessi's story.
Series
- Part 3 of Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club
-
Stacey's Sweet Spot by Marguerlucy
Fandoms: Baby-Sitters Club - Ann M. Martin, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Series - Alvin Schwartz
04 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
Stacey falls back into her bad food habits, and her face breaks out - but things are much scarier than they appear.
Disclaimer: the first few stories in this series use direct text from the Schwartz versions, but at reader request, I've stopped this habit as of Jessi's story.
Series
- Part 4 of Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club
-
Poor, poor Mallory! by Marguerlucy
Fandoms: Baby-Sitters Club - Ann M. Martin, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Series - Alvin Schwartz
05 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
A game of hide-and-seek turns deadly.
Disclaimer: the first few stories in this series use direct text from the Schwartz versions, but at reader request, I've stopped this habit as of Jessi's story.
Series
- Part 5 of Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club
-
Jessi and the Green Satin Gown by Marguerlucy
Fandoms: Baby-Sitters Club - Ann M. Martin, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Series - Alvin Schwartz
22 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
Jessi can't afford a whole new costume for Stamford Ballet School's upcoming performance. But the Porter Antique Shop may have the perfect gown...
A mash-up of Alvin Schwartz's Scary Stories series and the BSC.
Series
- Part 6 of Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club
-
You Gotta Hand it to Kristy by Marguerlucy
Fandoms: Baby-Sitters Club - Ann M. Martin, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Series - Alvin Schwartz
28 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
Kristy is sick and tired of Shannon Kilbourne and her stupid pranks. Maybe an extra-scary prank will end their Prank War once and for all.
A mash-up of Kristy and the Snobs and "The Dead Man's Hand" by Alvin Schwartz.
Note: I've made a mash-up for all of the main babysitters! I'm not as familiar with Abby, as I stopped reading the series before she entered. Should I do one for her? It might not be as good since I'm not familiar. I was also thinking of doing another round of stories for each babysitter, since there are so many scary stories that would still be fun to pair up with them. I'm happy to take requests or suggestions for a pairing!
Series
- Part 7 of Scary Stories to Baby-sit in the Club