1 - 20 of 105 Works in Pencey Prep (Band)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Jersey Dirt by bleedingfrommypen
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, I Brought You My Bullets You Brought Me Your Love - My Chemical Romance (Album), Tokio Hotel (Band), Pencey Prep (Band), Fall Out Boy, patrick stump - Fandom
08 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Gerard’s a mess—smeared eyeliner, paint stains, and whatever he had for lunch yesterday. But to her he was a voice.
Nia wants-well she moved to New York to figure that out. Well and to be with her best friend Mikey and her sister Sasha...didn't expect to like the shows so much.
Mikey keeps watch (unfortunately).
Frank can’t keep his hands to himself (that’s where Gerard gets it).
Kat just wants to see Paris—maybe end up in a song.Nobody’s who they say they are.
A slow-burn of messy friendships, fangirl origins, grief, and the ugly, dirty ways people find themselves under our nails.
Featuring: bad decisions, emotionally complicated baths, all the grimy queer vibes the '90s had to offer, and enough baggage to fill the Twin Towers(for now).
It’s not a love story. It’s worse.
It’s Jersey Dirt.
-
Tags
Summary
Frank's feet patter along the gravel, making his way off the pathway into the deep forest, the fur of his tail lightly brushing against calves - the tiny, ticklish feeling always seeming to aggravate him, as it’s one he’s not quite used to. Frank, aged 20, was just recently turned into a werewolf and it was in the stupidest way possible.
-
Straight Edge is Dead by cheesecakecj
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band), Fall Out Boy
06 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Frank Iero is obsessed with My Chemical Romance. Well, more like, just the singer. He thinks that this fixation of his will disappear once he gets to know Gerard better. Long story short, it does not go away. In fact, he can't help himself and needs to figure out what exactly Gerard is hiding, even if it means joining the band to figure him out.
-
I’ll Keep You Safe Tonight by DeadButDancing
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band)
03 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Gerard has been regressing to deal with the stress he’s under. He can’t sleep without slipping into a younger headspace. He makes a post on a forum, asking for a caregiver to help him out. Frank finds the post and decides that it’ll keep him occupied. I cannot stress this enough, there won’t be any NSFW.
-
Stranger Flirting Techniques by ApollosSwans
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band)
03 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
After a night of drinking, Frank finds himself stumbling into a stranger's car, with promises of getting a ride home. Little did he know, Gerard had other things in mind for him.
-
i'll betray myself; to anyone like you by bemeoume
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, LeATHERMØUTH, Frank Iero and the Patience, Frank Iero and the Future Violents (Band), frnkiero andthe cellabration, Pencey Prep (Band), Death Spells (Band)
27 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
one night i went outside to my back porch, smoked a very fine joint, came back inside and thought to myself "frank iero would give baller head i need to find a way to prove it" so--in a hysteria akin to one of a mad victorian woman with a quill and inkpot--i sat down and wrote this drabble on pen and paper. it took me 4 and a half pages of college-ruled notebook paper. i wish i was joking with you.
hope you enjoy! this is probably shit lol
-
Everything in it's right place by answeringmachines
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band)
22 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
When Gerard's roommate never shows up to their dorm, he thought he had the place to himself. He was wrong.
Things move on their own. Doors slam without warning. And someone—or something—keeps tidying up after his messes. It’s annoying, more than terrifying.
-
Anatomy Lessons by Weallfadeaway
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Bandom, Pencey Prep (Band)
05 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
"Gerard wasn't sure how he gotten talked into this. Somehow, his brother Mikey had persuaded him to help a friend of his through his first semester of art school by giving him lessons. And that kid was already fifteen minutes late for their first session... But, man, he hadn't mentioned just how fucking pretty he was!"
CHAPTER PREVIEW:
It was absolutely fantastic; he knew with his tutoring that Frank had improved, but... damn, he hadn't known just how much. Gerard was completely taken aback, enthralled in how beautiful it was, but also just how accurate he'd gotten all the details. He had to admit, he felt a little strange when Frank was explaining that it was for..."Wait, did you just say this was for your final?" Gerard exclaimed, embarrassment slamming down on him hard as the realization of Frank's words had hit him.
-
Romance (frerard) by Princessmawy
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep, frnkiero andthe cellabration, frnkiero andthe patience, Fall Out Boy
20 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Frank is Mr. Way's teacher's aide and he makes it his mission to make Mr. Way his boyfriend.
-
My Chemical (ro) Manse by URxBAST4RD (e4rlyXsuns3tz)
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Bandom, Thursday (US Band), Fall Out Boy, Pencey Prep (Band)
04 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Tuijottaessaan tölkkiänsä luultavasti jo monta tuntia sen jälkeen kun hän oli ensin kavunnut jakkaralle istumaan, hän huomasi hahmon asettuvan viereiselle paikalle. Fransin vilkaistessaan ylös, hän näki lyhyet vaaleat hiukset jotka istuivat pyöreiden, melko kevyesti meikattujen kasvojen ympärillä. Hän tunsi lämmön leviävän poskilleen katsoessaan ylös Gabin virnisteleviin kasvoihin.
Eli jos mcr olis perustettu Tampereella vuonna 2025. Also yaoi maxing idk :p
x
-
Fuck Authority - The Story Of A Cop & A Punk Boy by Koumori_chan
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep
02 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Fellas, is it punk to have gay sex with a cop?
A political, highly comedic alternate universe (circa early 2000s), where Frank is the singer of punk rock band Pencey Prep and Gerard is... a cop?! With his rebellious attitude and loud concerts, Frank ends up butting heads with the polite Officer Way many times. The tension builds between them until the lust can no longer be deterred, and Frank makes Gerard's questionable career choice a living hell ;) All while having to hide their "relationship" from bandmates and coworkers.
Eventually some spooky stuff happens too. Because why not? :D The two men grow closer as they explore haunted places around New Jersey (date night!). However, juggling their "relationship" becomes more complicated as Frank's touring schedule picks up and Gerard's responsibilities as a cop increase.
///
*Author's Note: I know the topic of cops is a controversial one in the alt scene and LGBTQ communities. The themes in this fic aren't pro-cop; it's more about questioning the current system from an objective standpoint. The system has been corrupt for a long time, but many people rely on it for better or for worse. How do we go about navigating such a system?
-
Drowning Lessons - Frerard by vjngette
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Frank Iero - Fandom, Gerard Way - Fandom, Pencey Prep (Band)
02 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Frank and Gerard meet under unfortunate circumstances. Frank sees his past self in Gerard as he watches him drown in his own sorrows. Frank helps Gerard, sees his potential and wants to pursue a friendship with him, a friendship that he hopes will turn into something deeper. A withdrawn Gerard won't make this easy for him as he stays lifeless and cold without a sound.
-
What makes you smile by el3ctricgh0st
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, LeATHERMØUTH, Pencey Prep (Band), Death Spells (Band), L.S. Dunes (Band)
30 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
Title from the song ‘Guilt Tripping’ by Frank Iero.
This is my first fic, idk what I’m doing and it's very unfinished but oh well :)
Just fluff where Frank and Jamia get ready for their date idk
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 995
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Hits:
- 38
-
WOULD WILLIAM MCMILLIN PLEASE REPORT TO THE MAIN OFFICE? by bones_baubles, N0SH0W5
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, I'm Not Okay (I Promise) - My Chemical Romance (Music Video), Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge - My Chemical Romance (Album), Pencey Prep (Band)
11 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
Illi is the same person she was a week ago. She’s laying despondently on her bed waiting for her alarm to go off, again. She’s the weird kid who sits in the corner and draws at parties; gets wasted in her room when Mikey goes out without her; can’t talk to people unless it’s about art, music, or her latest obsessions. She’s never gonna make it, as Ben so despondently told her one fall afternoon.
Or, my attempt at the I'm Not Okay verse.
I ONLY ADDED THE UNDERAGE SEX WARNING BECAUSE OF MENTIONS. IT'S UNLIKELY THAT I'M GONNA WRITE SMUT.
-
Tags
Summary
Gerard need to find a new place to fuel his unhealthy coffee habit. He finds South Bakery, where he meets Frankie. Frankie is a baker with a big toothy smile and with even bigger ambitions. Gerard is working in a dead-end cublicle job, while doodling his friends as batman-characters. They find they have a lot of in common, can they bring each other to higher grounds?
A cute story about meeting new friends, fullfilling carreer ambitions and finding new love.
MCR does not exist in this universe, friends and family of the main charachters will be OC.
-
The Comic-Con Incident by Anonymous
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band), Danger Days: The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys - My Chemical Romance (Album)
09 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
Struggling artist Gerard Way gets accepted to sell his KillJoys comics at a local con.
The band Pencey Prep is in town, and Mikey gets them to help run the stall.
Their guitarist, Frank, tags along in costume...Series
- Part 1 of I write ferard now
-
Like cheap whiskey, he’s always there by Prsandcnsofbreathing
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band)
06 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
“Night dude, this was fun” Gerard said. “Goodnight, you’re pretty cool you know” Frank responded before turning around and passing out.
-
Lovebites and Razorblades by 0P3NY0UR3Y3SANDL00KN0RTH
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band)
16 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
Inspired by a tweet <3
i’ve been loving all the new i’m not okay theories about gerard’s character being named illi mcmillin so…. HERE
If Illi McMillin was dating Pencey era Frank...
(this was also pretty heavily inspired by dinner in america so watch that movie too lolz) -
Hold you as waves crash down on the Jersey Shore by Z0mbicide
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Pencey Prep (Band)
06 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
Freezing white snow fell from the sky like an endless rain of cold needles on Frank's pale skin, the street lights flickered holding onto whatever sense of life they had left, a mixture of smoke and the winter air exhaled from Frank's lungs as he flicked the ash off his cigarette.
This would be an unexpected Christmas Eve
-
Temptation by mcr_rockstar
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Death Spells, LeATHERMØUTH, frank iero and the cellabration, Pencey Prep, Gerard Way and the Hormones
06 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
What happens when Frank meets a man, that's infatuated with him, in a mall, one Friday afternoon?