Archive of Our Own

Recent bookmarks

1. Public Bookmark 63

   but you still love me by strawbebbiecupcake

   Fandoms: The Sisters Grimm - Michael Buckley  

   • General Audiences
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • F/M, Gen
   • Complete Work

   26 Dec 2021

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Puck Goodfellow/Sabrina Grimm
   • Puck Goodfellow & Sabrina Grimm
   • Puck Goodfellow & Daphne Grimm
   • Hurt/Comfort
   • Injury
   • Sharing a Bed
   • Domestic Fluff
   • they're like 18/19 in this
   • dw tho there's nothing explicit!! just some dirty jokes and swearing :)
   • Idiots in Love

   Summary

   Puck hadn’t planned on getting into a fight with several giant scorpions and their creepy witch commander, but he has to admit it was very in character for both of them. Besides, before Sabrina got stabbed, he knows she was enjoying herself.

   Plus, there was the fact that they saved a couple people in the process, yada yada, but mostly it was something to help them both unwind.

   Again, until Sabrina got stabbed.

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   5,080

   Chapters:

   1/1

   Comments:

   28

   Kudos:

   356

   Bookmarks:

   63

   Hits:

   2,371

   Bookmarked by Pretty_in_Punk

   25 Apr 2026

2. Public Bookmark 7

   Wildlife Traps by pinkplasticflamingo

   Fandoms: The Sisters Grimm - Michael Buckley  

   • General Audiences
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • F/M
   • Complete Work

   19 Dec 2025

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Puck Goodfellow/Sabrina Grimm
   • Puck Goodfellow
   • Sabrina Grimm
   • Veronica Grimm
   • Shout out to pinklily8 for both motivating me on my Loyalties fic to write about what goes down in rings
   • and for writing a fairy ring fic of their own as well. Go read it.
   • There will be more plot than this one has.
   • Puck’s take on Sabrina is really truly “she has something wrong with her :hearteyes:”
   • ok so in wildlife studies there’s this issue that can sometimes arise
   • where study subjects learn that the scientists will always release them from the catch-and-release traps
   • and while in there they will attain the lure and also be inaccessible to predators
   • and they’ll start getting into the traps on purpose
   • are you seeing where I’m going with this.
   • do you guys ever wonder what that conversation must have been like when someone had to break the news to Puck that his dad was dead
   • and do you ever wonder what Veronica
   • who is very familiar with fairy nonsense
   • thought when she woke up from a coma to find the exiled prince had become very attached to her daughter
   • Puck got exiled ten years prior to canon. Sabrina’s eleven.
   • Henry and Veronica left Ferryport shortly after Sabrina was born if I remember right
   • meaning Veronica was sneaking around in Faerie for about a year before Puck left
   • at the very least she heard of him. But did they ever meet?
   • MB I’m begging you to do math before you create timelines I can’t keep finding implications like this
   • Fae & Fairies
   • Puck has daddy issues
   • I will not rest until that tag is canonized
   • One Shot
   • Post-Canon
   • Aged-Up Character(s)

   Summary

   Dozens of fairy tales contain the lesson 'don't hand yourself over to the fae, they might not give you back'.

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   2,266

   Chapters:

   1/1

   Comments:

   16

   Kudos:

   49

   Bookmarks:

   7

   Hits:

   291

   Bookmarked by Pretty_in_Punk

   25 Apr 2026

3. Public Bookmark 8

   Stuck in the Middle with You by pinkplasticflamingo

   Fandoms: The Sisters Grimm - Michael Buckley  

   • Teen And Up Audiences
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • F/M
   • Complete Work

   07 Nov 2025

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Puck Goodfellow & Sabrina Grimm
   • Puck Goodfellow/Sabrina Grimm
   • Puck Goodfellow & Jacob Grimm
   • Jacob Grimm & Sabrina Grimm
   • Sabrina Grimm & Mustardseed
   • Sabrina Grimm & Titania
   • Sabrina Grimm
   • Puck Goodfellow
   • Jacob Grimm (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Original Characters
   • Mustardseed (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Titania (The Sisters Grimm)
   • back on my
   • Fae & Fairies
   • lore bs
   • this girl doesn’t have one iota of sense when it comes to Puck. just zero self-examination
   • quietly staples in even more headcanons than last time
   • being annoying is a love language
   • Humor
   • well the narration is funny because Sabrina is funny but the situation is quite tough
   • playing around with Puck’s canonical alternating extreme jealousy and pushing away of Sabrina
   • Jealous Puck
   • There Was Only One Bed
   • except there literally wasn’t these two are just clingy
   • my goal dynamic was ‘married and they’re the last ones to know’ lmk if it worked
   • Some Swearing
   • some suggestive themes
   • all handled with the fumbling awkwardness of a pair of eighteen -year-olds and generally kept tame
   • alternate summary: Sabrina spends a few days asking herself ‘he’s a ten but he’s literally inhuman’
   • while having several of the worst meals of her life
   • title taken from the Stealers Wheel song
   • give it a listen sometime
   • previous fic was an adventure. this ones a romance

   Summary

   A year after Sabrina’s stay in the Seelie court and now that her grounding-until-graduation has ended, Titania asks her and Puck to travel back for a few days to tie up the loose ends that Sabrina left behind. Completely unrelatedly, Sabrina’s been researching how much business consultants charge for their services.

   Series

   • Part 2 of Plenty of Room at the Hotel California

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   23,892

   Chapters:

   7/7

   Comments:

   38

   Kudos:

   70

   Bookmarks:

   8

   Hits:

   693

   Bookmarked by Pretty_in_Punk

   25 Apr 2026

4. Public Bookmark 4

   Edge of Seventeen by pinkplasticflamingo

   Fandoms: The Sisters Grimm - Michael Buckley  

   • Teen And Up Audiences
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Gen
   • Complete Work

   24 Oct 2025

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Daphne Grimm & Sabrina Grimm
   • Sabrina Grimm & Little Red Riding Hood
   • Puck Goodfellow & Sabrina Grimm
   • Sabrina Grimm
   • Daphne Grimm (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Henry Grimm
   • Veronica Grimm
   • Relda Grimm
   • Little Red Riding Hood (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Jacob Grimm (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Mr. Canis | Tobias Clay
   • Mustardseed (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Titania (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Moth (The Sisters Grimm)
   • Puck Goodfellow
   • Original Characters
   • this fic is more playful than the following tags are about to imply the vibe is Percy Jackson quest not Euphoria
   • Cults
   • Fae & Fairies
   • sabrina grimm-centric
   • Family Dynamics
   • Drugs
   • at no point does the underage character do the drugs
   • heed my warning: I did drugs as a teenager and it put me in some harrowing situations
   • Sabrina is in a harrowing situation but at least she’s sober
   • Aged-Up Character(s)
   • she's seventeen
   • as the title implies
   • Humor
   • we're taking a good long look at Sabrina going into the Grimm business and her relationships with her family
   • Not Epilogue Compliant
   • this fic is going to be glued together by headcanons and fairy lore that MB forgot about
   • in aging up Sabrina I had to throw in some headcanons for flavor
   • I don’t think the hcs will be OOC but insert that one vine that’s my OPINION!
   • title taken from the Stevie Nicks song. give it a listen sometime

   Summary

   "Innocent until proven guilty" is less hard-and-fast than it seems once magic gets involved, and unfortunately for Sabrina, she's been considering public defense as a career option. She’s about to travel back-and-forth across the country and deep into modern Fae court politics— all for the sake of defending her own attempted murderer.

   Series

   • Part 1 of Plenty of Room at the Hotel California

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   20,865

   Chapters:

   9/9

   Comments:

   33

   Kudos:

   44

   Bookmarks:

   4

   Hits:

   484

   Bookmarked by Pretty_in_Punk

   25 Apr 2026

5. Public Bookmark 7

   Black Sheep by pinkplasticflamingo

   Fandoms: The Sisters Grimm - Michael Buckley  

   • General Audiences
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • F/M
   • Complete Work

   20 Sep 2025

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Puck Goodfellow/Sabrina Grimm
   • Puck Goodfellow
   • Sabrina Grimm
   • the other grimms make an appearance so miniscule i decided to not even tag them
   • lightly confronts the moral questionability of relda's attitude of 'everafters are people sabrina don't discriminate'
   • while also actively imprisoning them
   • kind of angsty and critical of the family as a whole but hey puckabrina happy ending
   • as in not the nuclear family boring ooc nonsense MB tried to feed us
   • takes a few details from the canon epilogues and rearranges so it's more satisfying
   • look basically it's the epilogues if they were good because despite what MB wanted us to think those were bleak
   • im incapable of writing Puck in any way other than as a certified yearner btw
   • Angst
   • Not Epilogue Compliant
   • Reunions

   Summary

   Jake texted him with just the words "Sabrina stopped aging" when Puck estimates he's physically about 24 or 25.
   He remembers what he's been putting off when he's talking to a troll in a bar in Thailand.
   "The Grimms took care of you? Weren't you lucky. Only one of that lot worth anything is Sabrina," he'd been told.

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   2,495

   Chapters:

   2/2

   Comments:

   3

   Kudos:

   65

   Bookmarks:

   7

   Hits:

   445

   Bookmarked by Pretty_in_Punk

   24 Apr 2026