16 Bookmarks by TheObserver_2395
List of Bookmarks
-
Filling inside Turn you outside by tentaclesfw (adorabilis)
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
02 May 2026
Tags
Summary
"How come you’re not jerking off?" His head snaps to you in response to that question, and the video quickly pauses.
"Why, you-you wanna watch?" His smile reached both sides of his cheeks.
"Don't be gross."
"You a-asked!"
"And you’re avoiding the question."
There is a brief pause during which you both just stare into each other's eyes. His smile falters, and you can't believe it, but a faint blush spreads across his cheeks. "I can't… cum."
You didn't mean to, but his admission deepened your grimace. Was he messing with you? For sure! "What the fuck are you talking about, you can't cum, like… Huh?"
A continuation, I suppose, of exploring the wonders of a Sex Life with Double T.
Series
- Part 2 of Double T
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
08 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You awaken in the back of a car, everything spinning and your thoughts slowed. You didn’t recognize the guy driving the car, but it was clear he knew all about you. If that sinister grin he shot you was any indication, he already knew just exactly what he wanted to do with you.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
06 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
toby steals ur underwear and jerks off lol. i suck at summaries
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
07 Jun 2026
-
Late-Night Visit (Ticci Toby x F!Reader) by leonst7rr
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
20 Aug 2026
Tags
Summary
Toby hasn’t had sex in a long time, so Tim and Brian take him out to break into your house and get laid.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
07 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Ask: Hey! Could you do a NSFW write for Toby x reader? I'm thinking the two of them had a bit of fun at a party and got heated in a cupboard or stall trying not to get caught, extra points for whiny breathy Toby o.o
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
12 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
[ticci toby x terminally ill reader short story]
After being given four months to live, you decide to spend it falling in love with the wrong person. Well, he is the right person for you. He's just the wrong kind of person to fall in love with.
So is a dying girl, but he doesn't seem to mind.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
25 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
toby usually tries to keep the more violent aspects of his life out of your line of sight, but after a mission gone awry you get a taste of his true self. literally.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
25 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You’re an apprentice piercer trying to build your portfolio as much as you can. How lucky is it, that you have a best friend who can’t feel pain?
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
24 Feb 2026
-
Like the romance novels (Erwin Smith x Reader) by hxrlxyltd
Fandoms: Shingeki no Kyojin | Attack on Titan
26 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
At a formal dinner, Y/N captures the interest of Captain Erwin Smith, a man who sees her intelligence and independence where her family only sees obligation. As shared moments during a seaside vacation turn into quiet intimacy, Erwin challenges her parents’ plans for her future, forcing both of them to choose between duty and a love that finally feels like freedom.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
22 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Your evening hike, which you had planned to share with friends, unexpectedly became a solo journey. The cold woods and an unsettling encounter with a man carrying hatchets made you question your decision on leaving the house. Wandering the dense forest would for sure leave you with memories you wouldn't forget.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
13 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
(Dark!Ticci Toby x F!Reader)
He was your brother's weird, creepy roommate he found through a Craigslist ad. Strange, scary, and always smelling of death and decay.
You were warned to stay away.
You didn't listen.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
07 Feb 2026
-
Deer Season (Tim Wright/Masky x F!Reader) by dirtyl0ver
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
17 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
It’s closing time in the shitty bar where you bartend, a place that should’ve stayed empty. Then he walks in, and suddenly you’re not sure if you’re serving a customer or feeding a predator.
"The evil is inside me. Inside all of us here. Let’s hope it doesn’t get you too."
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 172,233
- Chapters:
- 10/10
- Comments:
- 296
- Kudos:
- 1,003
- Bookmarks:
- 192
- Hits:
- 26,670
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
03 Feb 2026
-
Recruited. F Reader x Creepypasta by sugarkittys
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
23 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
THIS IS NOT MY WORK, a deleted fanfic originally written by HanaBanana on Quotev back in 2020
(Y/N) (L/N) was a girl who thought she did everything "right." A fresh university graduate, she begins her new life at a prestigious job in her dream city. Unfortunately for her, anxiety and paranoia begins to set in when a strange recruited being takes interest in her due to her dark past. Do they mean harm or an opportunity? Can she prove that she has the skills and smarts necessary to succeed? Can she do what needs to be done in order to survive? "We know that you have the capability to take a life"in my opinion, the best creepypasta fanfic oat, u wont be disappointed
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 269,306
- Chapters:
- 105/106
- Comments:
- 111
- Kudos:
- 341
- Bookmarks:
- 80
- Hits:
- 14,485
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
03 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
the real question is are u in the emh or is the emh in u. .... (reader insert fic where you, the reader, are a part of the emh crew. you fuck around and find out until u meet habit and he acknowledges how horny u are for him. lol) ((also a lot of this is not canon just to make it more like. reader-insert-y and also just because. lmao))
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
30 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Dozens of Slenderman drawings, reminiscent of Marble Hornets, which you were a huge fan of, were in a pile by the bin. Lists and lists of names under the title ‘Character Inspiration’ in a notebook on the desk. A Tarantino ‘Death Proof’ hat on top of a rucksack. Red lace.
You catch Evan with something that doesn't belong to him.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
28 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You had found Evan through an online listing for a room with reasonably decent rent, as long as you cover your portion of utilities. It is in a safe, quiet area, and Evan seemed like a really nice guy based on the texts you two sent back and forth. But what you did not expect was for him to be so attractive, or to be so capricious.
Bookmarked by TheObserver_2395
28 Jan 2026