1 - 20 of 94 Bookmarks by YayItsMay
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
A few years after the series finale, Lena decides it’s finally time to move on from her hopeless crush on Kara—by saying yes to a date with someone new. The problem is that Kara keeps getting in the way, and it’s driving her mad.
ORRRR“You’re doing it again,” Lena said.
“I’m not doing anything,” Kara insisted.
“You’re acting jealous.”
“I’m not acting,” Kara replied.Bookmarked by YayItsMay
12 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Lena knows.
Lena knows, because Lex told her before Kara got the chance to do it herself.
Kara knows that Lena knows because she tried to tell her, afterwards. They had an awful crying, shouting fight about it in Lena's office, the kind of fight that sticks under Kara's skin and keeps her awake at night.
(Kara accidentally crunched a handprint into Lena's desk. Lena threw Kara's phone off of her office balcony.
She doesn't want to talk about it.)
or: the story of what happens after Kara and Lena fall apart
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 29,939
- Chapters:
- 4/4
- Comments:
- 344
- Kudos:
- 6,436
- Bookmarks:
- 1,355
- Hits:
- 100,003
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
06 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Kara was about to head home, tired after a long day at CatCo and hours of patrolling the city, when she froze in midair. It took her a moment to realize what was wrong, why her heart was suddenly pounding in her ears. Because it wasn’t her heartbeat- it was Lena’s. The young Luthor had been attacked so many times that when Kara realized she had somehow already memorized Lena’s heartbeat she’d stayed tuned in (partly so she would be alerted if Lena was attacked, and partly to assure herself the woman was actually still alive). If Lena’s heart was pounding this hard… she was in danger.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 3,133
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 24
- Kudos:
- 1,428
- Bookmarks:
- 155
- Hits:
- 15,152
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
25 Nov 2025
-
Tags
Summary
“Kara!” Kara heard the sound of rustling sheets from the other side of the line. A creak of a headboard. “What’s-” A deep breath, “What’s up?”
Kara laughed, holding a hand over her mouth. “Uh, you know same old, same old. Just- um, looking in the mirror right now? And-” Kara paused, craning her neck to see the side of her jawline.
“And?”
“There are a lot of- of-” Kara licked her lips, “Marks.” She sighed when she heard Lena laugh from the other side of the line.
Supercorp College AU
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
30 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
“I’m a Luthor, Kara." Lena replied sharply, not interested in trying to smooth over the harsh truths like Kara was always so keen to do when it suited her. "No one wanted me there and they all made that very clear.”
“I wanted you there.” Kara replied so soft and earnest that Lena nearly believed her.
“I highly doubt that.” Lena scoffed derisively.
or,
It's Kara's birthday.
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
30 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
“Why does she get to touch you like that?” Kara asked when she could no longer hold the drunk-induced words back.
“Hmm?” Lena hummed, raising an eyebrow curiously as she tucked the duvet in around Kara’s heavy-limbed form, “Who gets to touch me like what?”
Kara pursed her lips, looking into the far corner of her room as she muttered darkly, “Andrea…”
Lena froze for a painful beat, and Kara was suddenly acutely aware of how her eardrums throbbed with the remnant bass of the club. Lena slowly pulled away standing up to her full height as she peered down at Kara, her expression inscrutable.
“Because she asked, because she showed interest.” Lena said eventually, the words clipped and sharp. “You’ve never even tried to touch me like that. Never given any indication that you would want to…”
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
29 Oct 2025
-
how do crows know when an earthquake is about to happen? by C_AND_B
Fandoms: Supergirl (TV 2015)
16 Apr 2021
Tags
Summary
“What do you want? When all of this is over, when you hang up the cape and let someone else take up the mantle of protector, what do you want?”
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
24 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Alicent sighs, nodding. Then just as Rhaenyra steps beside her, Alicent quickly reaches up to her on her tip-toes, pressing a soft kiss to Rhaenyra’s cheek.
“Sorry for slapping you.”
Rhaenyra freezes, staring at the sun setting while Alicent leans back down.
”It's okay, it was kinda hot.”
or a cute roommates to lovers halloween au
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
24 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
"And you are?" Lena says, holding her hand out to shake. Kara takes it, and puts in every effort not to crush it in her nervousness. Lena's hand is dry and cold where Kara's is uncomfortably hot.
"Kara Danvers," Kara says, putting on her best smile. "Reporter. It's great to meet you, I think we really – "
"Ah, Kara Danvers. The newest addition to the roster, and yet one who has her own private office on the 21st floor," Lena interrupts.
OR
How would early season 3 look if Lena and Kara didn't meet until after Lena bought CatCo, and Lena thought Kara was a total nepo baby?
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 114,168
- Chapters:
- 8/?
- Comments:
- 1,790
- Kudos:
- 11,443
- Bookmarks:
- 1,831
- Hits:
- 321,469
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
21 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Kara has been insufferable at game night. For whatever reason she's been so cocky about winning. But then Lena challenges her to a staring contest. Surely she can't lose to a human right? Lena has some tactics up her sleeve and won't go down without a fight. Speaking of sleeves... she might lose them during this staring contest ;)
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
16 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Sk8r Boi but make it Supergirl :)
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
16 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
After breakfast, Lena grabbed a blanket and her spellbook and went outside. Kara was sitting on the porch steps, talking on the phone with Alex. As Lena passed her, she gently stroked Kara's shoulder and then turned as she walked.
Kara looked her straight in the eyes: "Oh yes, sis, the view is simply breathtaking." Lena looked away and grinned to herself. Her friend is clearly flirting with her. She can't be imagining it all.
⸻ ☼ ⸻
Or: Kara and Lena are vacationing together in a tropical paradise and have to face their feelings for each other.
⸻ ☼ ⸻
Or: Continuing after the season finale. Supercorp is endgame. Supergirl's identity revelation leads to all sorts of problems.
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
13 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
“You’re a terrible liar, you know. You always were; it’s what made it hurt the most, when I realised that you’d been lying to me the whole time.”
“I’m sorry,” Kara breathlessly apologised, gripping her chest with one hand as she faced the door, her heart aching painfully.
“I missed you.”
Kara clenched her jaw as pain blossomed in her chest, her eyes burning as a pressure built up behind them, and she drew in a deep, shuddering breath, before her shoulders went slack, the breath rushing out of her all at once.
“I missed you too.”
“Stay for a bit, please. We have so much to catch up on.”
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 18,204
- Chapters:
- 3/3
- Comments:
- 288
- Kudos:
- 2,758
- Bookmarks:
- 392
- Hits:
- 34,274
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
09 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
“Is something wrong?”
“Oh,” the blonde quietly exclaimed, “no, I- well, I just- it’s not very- I mean … I don’t like it.”
A stony look stiffened Lena’s face as she jerked her chin up slightly. “Oh. Is there something else I can get you?”
With a weak laugh and a sheepish smile, the woman shrugged, “I mean, do you have anything … normal?”
“Normal?”
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 9,045
- Chapters:
- 2/2
- Collections:
- 2
- Comments:
- 87
- Kudos:
- 2,790
- Bookmarks:
- 266
- Hits:
- 22,173
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
09 Oct 2025
-
I Convince Myself I Have Answers, But I Always Call My Bluff by semperpugnandi
Fandoms: Supergirl (TV 2015)
27 Apr 2019
Tags
Summary
Desperate to figure out Lex's plan, Supergirl and Lena travel to Kaznia to unravel the mystery themselves. But when Eve puts Kara's life in danger, Lena ends up unravelling a secret much bigger than she expected.
A 4x20 identity reveal prediction.
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
06 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Written for #SCRiftWeek (Sept 21 prompt: Hate Sex).
After a midnight DEO lockdown strands Lena and Supergirl with a Luthor-locked control core, years of secrecy snap. Lena needles; Kara answers like a soldier, not a friend. The argument detonates into consent-checked, feral hate sex that doubles as a power struggle—Kara pins, Lena weaponizes the pin. They burn under blinking cameras until Alex erases the evidence. In the quiet aftermath, Kara admits: “I hid behind a symbol; you got trapped behind a surname.” The hate doesn’t end; it changes shape.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 6,674
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 27
- Kudos:
- 300
- Bookmarks:
- 38
- Hits:
- 4,315
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
23 Sep 2025
-
Tags
Summary
“My poor darling,” Lena says, teases. “Do you just go around licking anyone that smells like fruit?”
“No, I—I. Um.” Quiet. A steadying breath. “Now you’re just teasing me,” Kara murmurs, a dusting of red high on her cheeks. Lena’s delighted.
“First, you come into my home unexpectedly,” Lena says, and Kara whispers-justifies a quiet yeah, to cuddle, “and now you lick my neck. What’s next?”
Or, here's the thing: Lena has been in love with Kara for a long time. If Kara knows, then Kara doesn’t seem to mind.
Series
- Part 1 of let me be easy to love
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 28,099
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 5
- Comments:
- 246
- Kudos:
- 5,786
- Bookmarks:
- 1,113
- Hits:
- 118,988
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
22 Sep 2025
-
Tags
Summary
marrying the woman she loves in the name of friendship is easier said than done
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 57,832
- Chapters:
- 8/8
- Comments:
- 343
- Kudos:
- 2,227
- Bookmarks:
- 474
- Hits:
- 50,374
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
21 Sep 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Jealous and angry, Kara confronted Lena about her business with Reign.
Series
- Part 2 of Alien anatomy smut
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
17 Sep 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Lena can't hold back her jealousy when she sees James flirting with Kara, her best friend, but how can she justify her anger?
Angsty, possessive first kiss where Lena can't help herself anymore.
Bookmarked by YayItsMay
16 Sep 2025