14 Works by average_alternative
Listing Works
-
How About An Encore? by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale Yellow (Master Sword Video Game), Undertale (Video Game)
31 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
After witnessing Starlo look incredibly attractive during a performance, you can't help but do something about it.
I'm sure you all know what happens from there.
Series
- Part 10 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
Save a Horse, Ride a Cowboy by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale Yellow (Video Game), Undertale (Video Game)
17 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
Living in the Wild East with Starlo was great. For the first time in a long time, you found yourself truly happy. It seemed like coming to the Underground was the best decision of your life.
That happiness is threatened when the Asgore finds out that a human has been living in his kingdom for months without being caught.
OR:
I turn my fic that originally started out as smut oneshots into a fleshed-out story with angst, fluff, and yes... still more smut.
-
Starlo Kinktober Oneshots by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Master Sword Video Game)
14 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
You know the Kinktober list for this year? Yeah? Okay, well then... do you know me? Maybe? Okay, great. I'm sure you can put two and two together.
-
Addicted To The Cure by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
31 May 2025
Tags
Summary
The 5 times you kissed Starlo during an experiment, and 1 time that he got you back.
-
Come Hell Or High Water by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
03 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
After things get heated at Dina's saloon, you and Starlo head home to take a nice shower together.
I'm sure nothing could POSSIBLY happen during that time, right?
Series
- Part 9 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
A Short Tail Of Longing by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
13 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
Much like the LAST oneshot I put out, this one is also just pure smut. I've now officially reached over 100,000 words worth of Starlo fanfiction.
I have never been this horrendously down bad for a character in my life.
Series
- Part 8 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
Butterfly Kisses, Soft And Sweet by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
23 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
Pure smut and fluff. That's basically all I can say about this one.
Enjoy!
Series
- Part 7 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
SAHRAC Starlo NSFW Alphabet by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
09 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
If you're one of my friends irl and you've gotten the notification I've put this out... GO AWAY!!
Anyway.
I'm like 90% sure that somebody's already done one of these for Starlo, but I'm gonna take my shot at it. This will specifically be in reference to how Starlo is depicted in "Save a Horse, Ride a Cowboy", so if you want to have more context, feel free to read that.
Although, I have a feeling that most of you who read this will likely come from there anyway.
Series
- Part 6 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
Wonderful Nothing (Indulge In Yourself) by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
01 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
After Starlo gets impatient waiting on your return from the grocery store, he decides to indulge a little bit.
. . .
Just a little.
Series
- Part 5 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
A Balm For The Soul by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale Yellow (Video Game), Undertale (Video Game)
26 Oct 2024
Tags
Summary
After catching Starlo folding laundry while absolutely exhausted from the day, you decide to spoil him a little by giving him a nice massage...
... Because massages famously always stop at JUST the massage.
Series
- Part 4 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
Starstruck by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
26 Sep 2024
Tags
Summary
In general, the Underground was just a boring place to be. Monsters kept themselves enduring by forming connections with each other and inventing things, because what else were you supposed to do when you were trapped beneath the earth? You hated it. You oh-so-desperately wanted a taste for human life, for the Surface, for entertainment…
You wished upon a star, and boy did you get one.
OR:
Life in the Underground was always terribly boring for you, so you decided to move to the Wild East and get up to some bandit activities. Falling for the town's sheriff just so happened to be a little side-effect of that.
-
But When He Walks In (I Am Loved) by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
25 Aug 2024
Tags
Summary
A couple drinks in the saloon lead to first-time intimacy.
(Yes, your boy average_alternative is back with yet another Starlo smut fic. Original, I know).
Series
- Part 3 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
Hotter Than The Dunes by average_alternative
Fandoms: Undertale (Video Game), Undertale Yellow (Video Game)
05 Aug 2024
Tags
Summary
I like to headcanon Starlo as a lizard creature, and someone requested that I write this, so here we are. More Starlo smut because I'm mentally unstable.
I practically have a monopoly on the Starlo smut for this website at this point.
Series
- Part 2 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots
-
Something Much More Precious by average_alternative, StargazingMushroom
Fandoms: Undertale Yellow (Video Game), Undertale (Video Game)
21 Jul 2024
Tags
Summary
After Mooch steals more of your gold for the umpteenth time, you decide to take it straight to the sheriff. Unfortunately, all of the pent-up emotions you've been trying to ignore spill out the second you actually get him alone for a few minutes.
OR:
Another excuse to write more Starlo smut.
Series
- Part 1 of avg_alt's starlo smutshots