Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
Series Metadata
Listing Series
Pages Navigation
-
Payjanuary! (A month of Payjay fluff) by TallLiar
Fandoms: Inanimate Insanity (Web Series)
04 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
I love payjay, a lot! Especially fluffy payjay! So, I decided I’d start writing a short Payjay drabble every day for a month and chuck it at the world, because why not?
Ignore the fact I didn’t begin this at the start of the month. I had this idea spontaneously and didn’t want to wait until February
EDIT: fic name has been changed slightly, previously just titled 'A month of Payjay fluff!'
Series
- Part 1 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
- Part 1 of The Months of Payjay Fluff
-
Tags
Summary
Orange Juice is a contestant on Inanimate Insanity who spends a lot of time alone. A lot more than he thought he would when he joined.
You’d think with his smarts and planning skills, he’d have a better life than rotting away in the woods, but apparently not.
And it was only mere coincidence that what he missed happened to link back to those he pretended to bond with… he couldn’t miss them. What he missed was the idea of the competition, of winning the million. He missed his reputation. Not Paper, or Knife, or anyone he met along the way.
Right?
[SWAP AU!! A series of connected oneshots that follow OJ (swapped with Taco) as his perspective on life and relationships changes over the course of Inanimate Insanity.
ON INDEFINITE HIATUS]
Series
- Part 2 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ and Paper have been together for a while now. But lately OJ’s been drowning in his manager duties, oblivious to the way he neglects his lover.
He doesn’t notice his behaviour until the world he used to cherish comes crashing down around him, and the reality of the situation finally comes to light.
Series
- Part 3 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
- Part 1 of Payjay Hanahaki Trilogy
-
Tags
Summary
OJ’s been working all day… so Paper decided to take that opportunity to plan something special for them.
Series
- Part 4 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
It’s Paper and OJ’s first Valentine’s Day as a couple! They couldn’t be happier. Not everything goes according to plan, though…
Series
- Part 5 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ’s always been sure that his favourite colour’s orange. It was one of those smaller things he hadn’t given much thought. What else would it be? He was orange, his hotel was orange, the oranges in the trees outside his hotel are orange…
But of course, unforeseen circumstances end up forcing him to think about it a little more than he would’ve originally anticipated…
Series
- Part 6 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
(Based on a YouTube animatic by @Delusionality_! https://youtu.be/Jhwqe7a8yeA?feature=shared)
OJ’s… loved Paper for a while now. But he can never push himself to make that jump into asking him out. His fear just beat him to it every. Single. Time.
But one day the solution perfect solution to ALL his problems just… falls into his lap.
Marriage Fraud. An excuse to marry Paper, and make it seem as if it were purely for economic benefit. It’s a win all around. What could possibly go wrong?
Series
- Part 7 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
Paper wakes up in an unfamiliar, bright cyan void. Where was he? How did he end up here? And why did it feel like this wasn’t his first time here?
It was all so confusing.
Thank god he had OJ, his anchor, to help him figure everything out.
Series
- Part 8 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
No real summary this time… I literally just made this to cope with TNM6………
Payjay highschool fluff what more do you want from me
(now featuring merry crisis)
Series
- Part 9 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
[Fic requested by mcprincesspearl on discord!]
Paper’s been… pretty terribly treated for most of his life.
His father, Lifering, had died when he was only a child - and his step-mother Tea Kettle and his step-siblings Salt and Pepper seemed determined to make his life a living hell.
Will he be doomed to suffer in this endless cycle of abuse - or is there a chance that maybe, one day, there’d be a miracle to save him from this cruel fate?
Series
- Part 10 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
Time Travel. Sounds impossible, doesn't it?
Well, apparently nothing was impossible for a certain gravity-defying Marshmallow.
But after heading into the past with her to bring their old host back... OJ makes a choice. A choice to explore the limits of what this power could show him.
And... well, it's certainly an experience he'll never forget.
[Fic requested by hidingfrommilly on discord!!]
Series
- Part 11 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ's life was about as close to perfect as it could possibly get. Great friends, great grades, and a very long line of girls all lined up for a shot with the academic, athletic superstar.
So why did he still feel so... hollow?
And more importantly, why did that feeling get so much worse around PAPER, of all objects? After all, they were just friends. They'd been friends since they were kids.
His heart doesn't seem to get the memo, though.
[Fic requested by theblossomingfox on discord!!]
Series
- Part 12 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ’s been bottling up his feelings for quite a while now… but with a little encouragement from Pepper, he finally convinces himself to at least TRY to get them out in the open…
...But what the hell comes next? How would he go about taking that first step, and every other step on the unpredictable road destiny would put him on after that?
Well, he and a certain special someone would have to figure all that out on their own.
Series
- Part 13 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
It's Cold Outside (but we're warmer than ever) by TallLiar
Fandoms: Inanimate Insanity (Web Series)
07 May 2025
Tags
Summary
The world... had been quite cruel to Paper thus far.
His first friend ended up crushing him with a piano. A piano, for goodness sake. And of course, when he finally makes a connection that's actually meaningful - that person happens to get shot off a cliff by a lemon and dies.
And when he'd finally gotten used to living life peacefully in the hotel, with no competition to worry about.. the end of the world is suddenly approaching him like a freight train.
Could things get any worse?
The answer is… more complicated than what Paper initially expected.
Series
- Part 14 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ and Paper's first anniversary as a couple is coming up, and OJ couldn't be more excited. A chance to celebrate how far he and his lover had come over the years, and how much they meant to each other... it'll surely be a day filled with exciting revelations and surprises; one he'll surely never forget.
Series
- Part 15 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ's hotel has been absolutely BOOMING lately.
And that kind of success was... hard to manage, to say the least. Especially since OJ couldn't seem to find a good assistant to help out with things. He'd tried, sure, but all of them just... fell flat in one way or another.
So imagine his surprise when Steve Cobs, the CEO of Meeple Inc., offered to BUILD one for him.
Well... who was he to turn down the offer of a lifetime?
[Robot Paper AU! TW: Themes of implied/reference @bus3 will be scattered throughout the chapters.]
Series
- Part 16 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
- Part 1 of The SPARKVERSE
-
Payjuly! (A month of Payjay fluff 2) by TallLiar
Fandoms: Inanimate Insanity (Web Series)
30 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
YEAH WE'RE DOING THIS AGAIN. Are you even surprised at this point.
A short payjay drabble/oneshot every day for a month gay (straight)! I love this ship so much and it was really fun last time, so... I thought if it ain't broke, don't fix it, right? :)
Series
- Part 17 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
- Part 2 of The Months of Payjay Fluff
-
Tags
Summary
After the events of Season Four's first elimination, Paper asks his boyfriend for a very important favour.
Series
- Part 18 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ is sick and refuses to let Paper take care of him.
[Fic originally requested by 1stpin on discord!]
Series
- Part 19 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
OJ’s been working as a full-time police officer for quite a few years now.
It… wasn’t exactly all it was cracked up to be, but… he’d grown used to his current lifestyle, always being buried under pressure and having to face danger lurking behind every corner. Anything to make sure those criminals ended up behind bars, after all.
But while tracking down a certain ‘Hooded Bandit’ - a mysterious criminal who’d completed heist after heist without fail in just the span of a few weeks, he’s forced deal with the danger of letting the thief steal one of the most valuable things he had to offer; his own heart.
[Cop x Criminal AU, requested by starrless_ on discord!]
Series
- Part 20 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3