1 - 20 of 366 Works in Rob Cantor
Navigation
Listing Works
-
TALLY QUEST! by unknownbassist2008
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series)
11 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
The Tally Hall boys have been sucked into Joe’s old Gameboy. They’ve been imported to a fantasy like world, will they be able to fight their way out of good and evil? Or will they be stuck forever?
Series
- Part 1 of Tally Quest
-
Love is a gentle thing by Sedghiwitz
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series)
09 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
Andrew gets Zubin pregnant and Zubin’s trans uhh this was inspired my my old joebin fanfic also I had huge writer block and I locked the fuck in.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 1,726
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 2
- Hits:
- 69
-
in the white wood (wip) by robstrampoline
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Hawaii: Part II - ミラクルミュージカル | Miracle Musical (Album)
08 Dec 2025
Tags
-
The Michigan Boys ™ get isekaied into Hawaii Part II by pyriod_writr
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Hawaii: Part II - ミラクルミュージカル | Miracle Musical (Album)
08 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
Tally Hall's been transported to Hawaii, Part II. They all function as Simon and get into silly shenanigans!!! ENJOY SWEETIES<333
-
The Story of Good and Evil- A Tally Hall tale by Pomelo_peach
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Sacred Beast - Tally Hall (Song), A Lady - Tally Hall (Song), & - Tally Hall (Song)
04 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
Two brothers compete against each other for an opportunity to inherit the throne. What happens when a third, unlikely competitor becomes the key to victory in the most horrific way possible? Will the friendship that blossoms between the princes, the knight, an archer and a wizard be strong enough to overcome fatal fate?
Disclaimer- This story is loosely based off the Good & Evil album. I also want to clarify that this is not in any way shape or form a reflection of the real band- I just needed a few names for the characters and I happen to be extremely hyper-fixated on the band, so that's that.
Apologies for any bad spelling or incorrect grammar, feel free to correct me anytime.
-
Tags
Summary
So... Joe is now missing..
A Sequel to Missing Grey Tie
Series
- Part 2 of No Tallying in the Halls
-
shame on a martyr by categ0rical_0racle_xyZ
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series)
26 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
What if, one time, you tried to sing, and that was all you had left?
In which we deal with a loss of identity through a crippling change in Joe's six points of health, and how that may affect one's outlook on this miniscule game called Life and How to Play It. What would change for you, or anyone, for that matter, as you slowly lost the ability to exist as you once did?
-
Take a Trip to the Minimall by rokpaprsizors
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series), Banana Man - Tally Hall (Song), Ruler Of Everything - Tally Hall (Song), The Whole World and You - Tally Hall (Song), Undertale (Video Game)
25 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
Today is Zubin's birthday, and his birthday gift is a trip to the all-new Tally Hall 2! Unfortunately, Joe and Ross are captured by the Banana Man and Casey dies. It's up to the remaining 4 Tally Hall members and Sans to rescue Joe from being constantly trafficked by several villains from their songs.
Series
- Part 1 of Undertally Hall
-
Tally Hall x Reader Oneshots (ended) by vexelist
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series), Good Day - Tally Hall (Song)
25 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
idk what i'm doing.....I'm bored and I love tally hall sm!!
!! ALL READERS ARE AGED UP !!
-
Tally hall jokesmut 😝 by projektrevfranklover
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series)
21 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
This is all meant to be funny, nothing more ^^
written by my friend sage who does not have ao3 :( i edited this ^^
original story (not updated or edited by me and like 3 years old) : https://www.wattpad.com/story/361047596-tally-hall-smut-%F0%9F%98%AD
-
Tags
Summary
What if the Tallies were really animatronic? (That’s it)
More normal attraction than FNAF, still with sentient robots though, of courseSeries
- Part 4 of Cant’t spell autism without AUs
-
Tags
Summary
inspired by cyber sex, which is a fic im sad never got more than one chapter
the band has fallen on rough times financially, and ross needs cash. after lamenting to his bandmates, they suggest he try camming. desperate times call for desperate measures, right?
-
An Attempt at an Evil Hall X Reader Request Book by mx_adjective
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall vs Evil Hall (Comic)
16 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
I have read the comic on Tumblr about a month ago, and I must say, I liked it a lot One search on AO3 later, I was met with almost no content! So, I am taking matters into my own hands.
Feel free to request x Reader content with the Hallies! I don't bite, I promise :)
-
Tags
Summary
Kinda inspired by Puella Magi (Madoka Magica). The stars ask Tally Hall(via dream) if they want to become magical boys, but things are not as simple as they seem
-
Tags
Summary
The Tallies go on a trip to Canada for a bit, however their trip gets taken for a ride and one of them goes missing..
Series
- Part 1 of No Tallying in the Halls
-
Tags
Summary
Banana man
-
If you marry me, would you bury me? by Soda_Fizzy
Fandoms: My Chemical Romance, Green Day, Fall Out Boy, Tally Hall (Band)
23 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Four bands end up in an abandoned school. or so they thought. They are in a killing game. Who makes it out alive? Who dies? Who is behind it all?
-
Tags
Summary
6 marionettes. Joe the Red, Zubin the Blue, Rob the Yellow, Andrew the Green, Ross the Grey and Bora the Orange Unfinshed. Each made from wood, with highly realistic hair, formal clothes and coloured ties.
'Hey ho don't cha know its a good ol' fashion puppet show, that's right quite the set, we're the Marionette Quintet'
A puppet maker crafts each one with his whole heart and soul. Before dissapearing and being unable to finish the last.
AND NOW THEY R A SILLY BAND AND WATCH THEM GO WOOP WOOP 🥳🥳 (it gets dark later on.)
I keep changing things & the lore so if you want to read new chapters, you may wanna re read.
-
Weirdmageddon with Chris Dunne and Will Wood (and others) by LaplacesLawyer
Fandoms: Life In The World To Come (Podcast), Tally Hall (Band), Lemon Demon (Musician), Gravity Falls
19 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Will Wood and Chris Dunne find something that could save their career as apocalypse theorists.
Tally Hall ends up in the wrong place at the wrong time.
Neil Cicierega helps write some music.
All three of them were on seperate paths, but they met just once, and it would change their lives forever.
-
The Mechanical Shop by SomeInternetFreak
Fandoms: Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series), Hawaii: Part II - ミラクルミュージカル | Miracle Musical (Album)
14 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
A shop of puppets and entertainment for all, music and stories you’ll never forget.