bigpapa_pickle
Fandoms
Recent works
-
Tags
Summary
ORIGINALLY POSTED ON WATTPAD: @kraffmacaronii,
https://www.wattpad.com/story/408292733-on-line-creepypasta-fic
Texting fic: lowercase intended
Multiple parts will be posted at once.
NO AI WAS USED IN ANY OF THIS"You were desperate enough to hire a killer"
-
Tags
Summary
"So stick him in a dress and he's the only boy I'd bag
The only boy I'd anything is Toby in drag
I'll never see that girl again he did it as a gag
I'll pine away forevermore for Toby in drag"based off of semi-true events and the song: Andrew in Drag
-
Tags
Summary
It was wrong for you to feel this way for him. Yet, you still did.
Recent bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
It's him.
It has always been him.
Jeffrey Alan Woods.
Your mouth fell open. At the same moment, his gaze found yours, and his smile split wider, stretching from one cheek to the other in something that was almost too large for a human face. Like he had been waiting for exactly this moment and found it every bit as satisfying as he'd imagined.
He reached up and pulled the mask down.
The scar revealed itself slowly. You knew that face. You had tried very hard to disbelief it.
"Miss me yet?" His voice carried the grin in it, light and easy, the way someone speaks when they already know the answer. Like a child who has just unearthed a toy they buried themselves in their backyard, delighted by the finding.
Bookmarked by bigpapa_pickle
02 Jul 2026
-
Collection of Headcanons & Drabbles (Various Creepypasta x F!Reader) by dirtyl0ver
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
13 Jul 2026
Tags
Summary
A growing collection of Creepypasta x F!Reader headcanons featuring all your favorite killers.
Expect everything from cute moments to total angst!
(Includes Ticci Toby, Tim/Masky, Brian/Hoodie, Jeff the Killer, BEN Drowned, and Eyeless Jack)
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 91,515
- Chapters:
- 84/84
- Comments:
- 343
- Kudos:
- 2,554
- Bookmarks:
- 239
- Hits:
- 69,387
Bookmarked by bigpapa_pickle
20 Apr 2026
-
Misanthropy (Jeff the Killer x Ticci Toby) by OofMyNuggets
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
12 Jun 2021
Tags
Summary
mis·an·thro·py /məˈsanTHrəpē/
noun
a dislike of humankind.
"the streak of misanthropy in his nature"
Bookmarked by bigpapa_pickle
16 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You hate Toby Rogers. Hate. He’s immature, and whiny, and gets in your way more often than not. Proxies are meant to work together, but you two just don’t. Fights are prone to happen, but when your hands accidentally find his throat, Toby accidentally finds out that he likes it. You hate him. And he hates you. So why can he suddenly not jerk off without thinking about your hands on his neck? Why does he want you to do it again??
Bookmarked by bigpapa_pickle
16 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Having an imaginary friend is a very normal part of childhood. What isn't normal, though, is when that imaginary friend begins to show up in the corners of your vision, leaving you presents and an uneasy feeling. What happens when babysitting a little boy turns into fending off his protector? The worst part? He thinks you're very, very pretty.
Bookmarked by bigpapa_pickle
09 Apr 2026