MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
Series Metadata
Listing Series
-
Tags
Summary
The night couldn't get any worse than that, or so they thought.
After hours of wandering around the forest for a stupid mission, the only thing they wanted was to get home, eat some leftover pizza and pass out. But once they were approaching their cabin, so close to their sweet rest, Toby starts acting strange, leaving Tim and Brian to find a way to save the kid when they are miles away from the nearest hospital.
-----
or Toby drinks an unlabeled bottle from an abandoned house and Tim and Brian have to make him puke his brains out so he doesn't die :)
-MO3
Series
- Part 1 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
He wasn't sure if he was awake or still tangled in a never-ending nightmare, all he knew was that he wanted everything to stop.
His father raised a fist at Toby, threatening with another blow, as if the kid hadn't had enough already. He could hear his mother crying in the living room, holding her sister tightly so they didn't have to see the atrocity that was unfolding next door.
Toby knew he was beyond salvation. He knew no one would come to save him, that tonight he'd have to rock himself to sleep outside of his parent's door, hearing their slowed breathing, imagining that it was different, that he got to sleep on their bed and be cuddled and loved until he dozed off.
No one would save him, right?
----
or Toby has a panic attack due to a nightmare and stays outside Tim and Brian's bedroom door like he did when he still lived with his parents. Will this time be different?
-MO3
Series
- Part 2 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
Brian sipped from his cup, shrugging.
—Just shave it then.
Toby paused for a second, the tea growing colder in the cup. He tilted his head, his thoughts coming at miles per hour at him. He knew he couldn't remember some things from his past, but this wasn't one of them. No, of course, this was the first time he was growing facial hair, so he had no experience with it.
—I don't really k-know how —He simply replied.
Tim and Brian shared a glance, both sipping from what seemed to be never-ending cups of coffee.
----
Or, as some time has gone past, Toby realises he's growing a bit of a beard and his dad never taught him how to shave.
Short and cute fic about Toby learning things his dad should've tought him when younger :)
Series
- Part 3 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Lay your weary head to rest [MO3] by Anonymous
Fandoms: Marble Hornets, Creepypasta - Fandom
09 Aug 2026
Tags
Summary
—Shouldn't we get him a warm bath? —Tim asked, still holding Toby's hand outside of the blankets.
—If you wanna give him a heart attack then sure, but it's better if we stick to the blankets —Brian replied, focused on tucking the extra bits of the blanket around Toby's shape.
Tim fell silent for a second, reflecting on his lover's words.
—Damn, I don't know what I'd do if you weren't here, birdie —Tim replied, voice serious— I could've killed the kid...
Brian smiled warmly, looking at him with sweet eyes.
—Then it's a relief we got eachother, right?
---
Or Toby gets hypothermia, then overheats and THEN has a panic attack. His day is just terrible. I promise this is cute and fluffy, I just like making him suffer too
Series
- Part 4 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
I buried the past for a reason [MO3] by Anonymous
Fandoms: Marble Hornets, Creepypasta - Fandom
12 Aug 2026
Tags
Summary
—I can fix him —Skully declared once more.
—You can't take him away from us, Skully —Brian pleaded, his voice starting to shake. He wanted to sound threatening, but he wasn't able— It's not what Jay would want. You know Tim wouldn't want it either.
Skully nodded slowly but still let out a long sigh before opening his hand, releasing the other's arm.
—We'll think of something just...—Brian was at a loss for words. Toby hid behind him, gripping the back of his shirt. Dark brown eyes glared at them— Just go. He doesn't like it when you're here. I don't want to anger him more.
Skully turned around peacefully understanding. Brian just nodded at him and watched as a dark portal emerged to his side and swallowed Skully until he dissappeared.
Which then left them alone before one whom they hadn't seen in a while.Masky.
-----
Or Skully visits Tim, Brian and Toby before Tim has a seizure and a certain someone emerges.
Series
- Part 5 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
Brian didn't want to count how long it had been. He thought he had everything under control. He missed Tim a lot, more than anything, his heart was shredded into pieces, but he was able to keep going without stalling in his own sadness.
He tried to ignore his sadness as best as he could—he didn't want to accidentaly manifest anything—, but sometimes it was too hard. He sat on the porch and pressed a cigarette against his lips.
The bitter taste of tobacco made him miss Tim even more.
---
Direct sequel to "I buried the past for a reason", although I think it's understandable enough to be read separatelyHope you enjoy!
Series
- Part 6 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
—See something you like? —He jokes, extending his arms to present his body even further.
—Fuck, I'm seeing something I love...—Brian blurted out, not caring how cheesy nor desperate it sounded.
They kissed once more, this time unable to hide how desperate they were feeling for eachother. When Brian moved on to kiss Tim's neck, he felt how his cock twitched, accompanying the broken moan Tim had let out. He couldn't get enough of this feeling. Brian really wanted to see where that happy trail led to.
---
Or Tim and Brian make love romantically :)
Placed some time after "Be Nice to Me"
Consider this an apology for making everyone suffer last time hahaha
Series
- Part 7 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
—Operator got you too?
—It tried, but it can't control me.
—And why is that? —Tim decided to finally use his voice, but he had sounded a bit too intrusive, he reflected.
He was met with a shrug.
—Can't really control a demon.
Tim's eyes widened painfully.
—A what?
---
Or, small snippets of Toby finally making a friend! And maybe something more... :)
Series
- Part 8 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
I don't believe in ghosts [MO3] by Anonymous
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
03 Sep 2026
Tags
Summary
—Y-yeah, some air w-will be fucking nice —He spat, almost completely out of the kitchen now— Maybe I'll be luc-cky and die on my w-way there, since it s-seems no one c-cares about what I d-do here.
He didn't really know why he said that, since he didn't feel like dying would help at all, but what he knew is that that sentece probably hurt deeply. And as his mind was still twisting and turning in the heat of the moment, that's why it rolled off his tongue so easily. Tim and Brian had a horrified expression on their faces when Toby stormed out of the kitchen, hearing them telling him to come back loudly, but Toby had already made his way to the door and shut it with force before his boots his grass and he ran to the bus stop, fists tight and heart heavy.
---
Or Toby gets into a stupid argument with Tim before a mission where he has to face her sister's lookalikeBasically his day couldn't get any worse
Series
- Part 9 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
—Wanna k-know a secret?
Jack nodded, although he wasn't really sure what this secret could be. With Toby anything could happen, he was a box full of surprises.
—My d-dads are out for the night...
He wasn't sure how actually alive he was, but Jack swore he could feel his face blushing. His breath hitched on his chest and he could only let out a soft giggle when Toby elbowed him, unable to contain his happiness.
---
Or Toby and Jack finally have a normal date and can't keep their hands to themselves
Series
- Part 10 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
Tags
Summary
—Where are you? —Tim quickly asked as Toby heard shuffling and movement on the other side of the line.
—D-Dunno...—He answered, trying to look around but his eyes were unfocused— Somewhere n-near that run down d-diner we went to the o-shit-other day...
—Don't move, okay? —The sound of a car starting made the pressure he felt in his head worse
The skin in his arms had goosebumps all over like it was trying to feel the air around him. It's like his body was shivering in anticipation for something, but Toby didn't know what it was.
Well, of course he didn't know, he hadn't really felt it before.
Pain.
---
Or Toby messes up on a mission and the Operator punishes him a bit too harshlySeries
- Part 11 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
I still think you're beautiful [MO3] by Anonymous
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
27 Sep 2026
Tags
Summary
He wiped his tears, probably smearing some blood on his cheeks, and took a deep breath. He wanted Jack. He wanted Tim and Brian. He needed someone to tell him that what he was doing was wrong, but he found himself unable to move from his bed. Did he deserve someone rescuing him after willingly doing this? After mauling his body into a red mess?
He felt stupid for what he had done. He was getting better, why did he have to ruin it again?
---
Or Toby relapses, but he has people who are more than willing to care for him
Series
- Part 12 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
What's going on in that beautiful mind? [MO3] by Anonymous
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
06 Oct 2026
Tags
Summary
It was stupid, right? He shouldn't be this afraid to ask a question, especially if it was Brian, his lifelong companion, his soulmate even.
But Tim had established a deadline for himself, or else he knew this would never happen. It had to be today, no exceptions.
He was used to facing a lot of things with fear in his heart, but this had to be one of the hardest ones yet. Nonetheless, he sighed, hiding his hand again in his pocket and closed his eyes.
---
Or Tim and Brian put a ring on it before skipping everything and going straight to the wedding night ;)
Series
- Part 13 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots
-
If you love me let me go (and run away before I know) [MO3] by Anonymous
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
11 Oct 2026
Tags
Summary
A crash, a broken window, foreheads on the dashboard, blood on their faces.
He couldn't believe it was happening again.
Toby couldn't believe he would loose them too like this.
---
Or Tim, Brian and Toby get into a car crash, making Toby's trauma erupt once more
Series
- Part 14 of MO3's Tim, Brian and Toby oneshots