1 - 20 of 24 Bookmarks by most_unlikely
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Nancy and Robin both realized they were into each other a little earlier than they might like you to think. It took the world almost ending for them to do something about it.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 41,304
- Chapters:
- 15/15
- Comments:
- 263
- Kudos:
- 1,434
- Bookmarks:
- 275
- Hits:
- 33,375
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
30 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Robin Buckley is a homosexual with issues. Nancy Wheeler, a bisexual with her own problems, notices those issues and the two slowly go from hating each other to not being able to live without each other, slowly finding their footing in a relationship that the world doesn’t want them to have. In other words: Robin and Nancy do a sapphic slow dance around each other until everybody else notices.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 77,358
- Chapters:
- 36/45
- Collections:
- 2
- Comments:
- 405
- Kudos:
- 2,012
- Bookmarks:
- 265
- Hits:
- 74,692
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
29 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
It’s winter in Hawkins, and Mike and Will aren’t speaking anymore. Living in Mike’s house, Will tries to be invisible, spending most of his time in the basement.
Then the power goes out — and if there’s one thing he dreads more than facing Mike, it’s the cold.
or
Seven nights in which Mike and Will have to sleep in the same bed, even though they’re barely friends anymore.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 52,439
- Chapters:
- 8/8
- Comments:
- 14,338
- Kudos:
- 200,880
- Bookmarks:
- 30,724
- Hits:
- 2,749,270
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
28 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
What if a farm is an escape? What if city and country collide? What if you have to face the past to have a future? What if dreams can be found in the flights of butterflies and fireflies?
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 112,111
- Chapters:
- 87/87
- Comments:
- 989
- Kudos:
- 1,014
- Bookmarks:
- 27
- Hits:
- 22,275
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
15 Oct 2023
-
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
26 Aug 2023
-
Tags
Summary
Ellie and Aster are in the same choir/band. An alternative universe where they get an opportunity to meet without Paul's letter
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
25 Aug 2023
-
Tags
Summary
In 1943, Carson Shaw and Greta Gill fell in love. In 2011, everything they once thought was impossible is finally within their grasp.
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
25 Feb 2023
-
acts of service (unlikely valentine) by meren_plath
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
14 Feb 2024
Tags
Summary
as greta struggles to find her love language, she plans a different valentine's day with carson.
-----
the valentine's day smut!!!
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
15 Feb 2023
-
Midnight Snack by crsonshaws
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022), A League of Their Own (TV 2022) RPF
12 Feb 2023
Tags
Summary
Update #140 of Call It What You Want: A Gretson SMAU
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
12 Feb 2023
-
Tags
Summary
if you were a church, i'd get on my knees
confess my love, i'd know where to be
my sanctuary, you're holy to mecarson knows greta's struggles with religion, so they set up a plan to help her, once and for all.
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
06 Feb 2023
-
Girl of my Dreams [The Story Behind The S(ex) Tapes] by Folklorian97, Verysadgill
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
26 Aug 2023
Tags
Summary
Five years before she slept in Carson’s New York City apartment and six years before she moved to New York herself, Greta Gill met Carson Shaw in an underground comedy club in Los Angeles, California. Their story of love and heartbreak, of years-later hookups and thought-they-were-cheatings, of jealousy and growth – it would all be the inspiration for Greta’s first TV show. The one that would, by fate or Cari Fletcher’s hand, bring them back together.
-------
This story predates "The S(ex) Tapes AU" on Twitter (@thesextapesau). We recommend you get caught up over there (through update 33) before beginning this fic.
Fic and AU inspired by FLETCHER's discography (especially her ep THE S(EX) TAPES).
Enjoy!
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
04 Feb 2023
-
Tags
Summary
I don’t think you can really blame me.
Or, Carson’s hated going shopping all their life, but when Greta says, “Trust me,” Carson can’t help but give her a chance…and a hand.
For just one
of these fantasies I've kept inside till now
Lead me on, I will follow gladly
Please don't be mad at me because I let it show
Is it so wrong to want you so badly?
You got the power that I know I can't resist
My heart is pounding and I'm bound to take the risk
For just one kiss.
—Alannah MylesSeries
- Part 3 of Runaway Series
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
30 Jan 2023
-
as the sun waits to eclipse (i won't let go) by ifthebookdoesntsell
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
29 Jan 2023
Tags
Summary
Things in Rockford are slow, but Carson Shaw is fast. Carson Shaw is fast and fervent and the first thing that Greta thinks about each morning, and she hasn’t felt this way in years. She hasn’t let herself.
But Carson is here and real and present, and she isn’t going anywhere. Greta isn’t used to a paradise that doesn’t taste like running, but she finds it in Carson. Carson tastes like a walk-off homer after a twelve-inning game. She tastes like that moment in the dugout when you watch it soar towards centerfield. She tastes like victory, the split second where the world is yours. Where the sky is yours. Where everything is yours. And nothing has ever been Greta’s, not like this.
Carson tastes like a moment frozen. She makes an honest woman out of Greta in these stolen seconds, kisses her like she’s never told a lie – and Greta is pretty sure Carson hasn’t. She kisses her until Greta is spilling truth, telling her about all of the lives she’s lived, about the friends she’s had that no longer exist, all of the ghosts.
(Or, a study of Greta and time.)
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
29 Jan 2023
-
Tags
Summary
"I'm really glad you're in my life."
There's a weight to those words and Coley's aware of it, but it's a comfortable weight, the kind that's heavy and feels good to rest on, because if something is heavy then it has weight and if something has weight then it must mean more than something.
Maybe Coley's just overthinking it.
.
girl grows up with girl and girl falls hard for girl.based on the lovely music video girls like girls, by hayley kiyoko
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
29 Jan 2023
-
Tags
Summary
They didn’t speak. They didn’t need to. Their lips found each other naturally, and moments later, Carson had her panting over the desk. Greta covered her moans with the back of her hand as she came loose under their touch.
Or how Greta and Carson went from just being work colleagues to…this.
update: thank you for all the lovely comments, i won't be updating this fic any longer sorry :(
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
24 Jan 2023
-
Fifty Shades of Gill (A Darker Shade of Peach) by LSgrimm91, saltwatersiren
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
22 Oct 2023
Tags
Summary
*Complete*, *Images updated*
A favor for her sick room-mate brings journalist Carson Shaw to meet Peaches Sportwear CEO Greta Gill, who flips Carson's world upside down. But Greta has her own baggage and Carson must deal with her pesky fiancé first.We took all the nonsense, bad dialogue, and awful content out of Fifty Shades of Grey, and replaced it with healthy communication, respect and consent. Nothing is gratuitous in here; it's now an epic Gretson romance story.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 261,437
- Chapters:
- 29/29
- Comments:
- 1,432
- Kudos:
- 1,487
- Bookmarks:
- 166
- Hits:
- 79,518
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
14 Jan 2023
-
i want everyone to look at me (the way they look at you) by ifthebookdoesntsell
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
03 Jan 2023
Tags
Summary
For so long, Carson believed that love came from wanting everything somebody else had that you didn’t. That love came from the fact that somebody might fill in those parts of you.
She convinces herself she loves Charlie because of it.
Charlie isn’t a girl. He is strong and handsome, that’s why he gets to play baseball with the boys. He’s not a girl, and he gets to do all of the things that Carson doesn’t. All of the things Carson wishes she could. He is all of the things Carson knows she is but doesn’t get to call herself.
--
Greta is a woman. Carson knows this for sure, and she can’t feel this much for a woman. She can’t. But then, Greta smiles at her, takes her hand, pulls and says, here’s your destiny, and Carson thinks that maybe she is the kind of person who has a destiny after all. Destiny looks like red hair and dark eyes.
Salvation.
(Or, Carson, growing up, gender envy, and falling in love. How Carson grows into the person she always thought she was inside. My take on a Carson gender exploration.)
Series
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
04 Jan 2023
-
Glimpses Beneath the Fold by karalovesallthegirls for salsayourface
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
15 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
Detailed snapshots from a Twitter-based Celeb Social Media AU called "Above the Fold"
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 142,593
- Chapters:
- 12/13
- Comments:
- 373
- Kudos:
- 1,394
- Bookmarks:
- 112
- Hits:
- 39,708
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
29 Dec 2022
-
Tags
Summary
Now that Charlie knows about Carson and Greta, he'll do whatever it takes to save his marriage. Even if that includes threatening to out Greta. So, when they're back at Rockford, Carson has to act distant to protect the woman she loves.
(or what happens after the end of season one)
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
20 Dec 2022
-
saying all of this would ruin the moment (you touch me like nobody else does) by ifthebookdoesntsell
Fandoms: A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
10 Feb 2023
Tags
Summary
“She’s not my girlfriend,” Greta hisses, even as she watches the game, watches Carson leading off second base, the focus in her jawline, the flex of her calves, that stupid cap on her head.
“Oh really?” Maybelle leans over Jess. “Then why are you drooling?”
Greta’s face goes hot. “I’m not fucking drooling!” she hisses. “Carson and I work together.”
“Yeah, I’m sure you do lots of things together,” Jess quips, proud of themself.
Swallowing hard, Greta steels her resolve. They’re getting too close to the truth. She has to remember the rules she and Carson drew up in the back of class once – they should have been taking notes, but Carson’s hand was on her knee, her thumb drawing circles, so she spent most of class just doing her best to keep a clear head.
“Really, Carson and I are just friends,” she says, firm. “She has a boyfriend.” And that part is true at least. Carson isn’t her girlfriend; that’s Greta’s entire problem.
(Or, a modern-take on the affair and how it might play out if they were allowed more choices, for better or for worse. The one where they're in college, they're co-workers, they can't keep their hands off each other + they just really need to get their shit together.)
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 53,700
- Chapters:
- 12/12
- Comments:
- 792
- Kudos:
- 1,533
- Bookmarks:
- 237
- Hits:
- 47,860
Bookmarked by most_unlikely
26 Nov 2022