1 - 20 of 210 Bookmarks by plckyourfilter
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Following the events of my previous fic, Simpler Said Aloud.
Everyone knows, from here to Saint Denis, that you and Arthur Morgan mix like oil and water. To say it’s as simple as that is the greatest understatement of the century though, because this feuding of personalities isn’t just like oil and water, it’s like gasoline and open flame – it’s explosive and, a bit like arson, isn’t something you want to stand too close to.
But, things change.
Series
- Part 2 of Simpler Said Aloud
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
19 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
By 1899, the age of outlaws and gunslingers was at an end. A new century was coming. One without any mercy for those still caught up in the wild past.
A runaway from an affluent family up North, you were brought into the Van der Linde gang by a strange turn of fate. Helpless, lost, and very far out of your own depth, you would have never expected to fall for an outlaw. Let alone two. But fate is a strange and cruel mistress, and you inexplicably found yourself senselessly and irrevocably in love with both John Marston and Arthur Morgan. A woman of society and civilization, tangled up with two of its greatest enemies.
Now, you must confront the wrongs rooted within the outlaw way of life, the ghosts of your past, and the part that you will play in a collapsing gang as the Wild West is eaten alive by modernity's gnashing teeth. And somehow, along the way, you must mend your tattered bonds with the men you love and the people you hold dear.
In which Arthur Morgan learns to forgive, John Marston learns to strive, you learn to sew, and you all find your redemption, be it red or otherwise.
Series
- Part 3 of Lessons
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 290,047
- Chapters:
- 35/35
- Comments:
- 774
- Kudos:
- 1,194
- Bookmarks:
- 170
- Hits:
- 48,331
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
18 Feb 2026
-
like honey that dips so sweet (how desperate my grizzly needs) by Anonymous
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
09 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
After Jack gets in trouble for showing up to school late, again, it's up to Arthur to make sure he gets to school on time. He just didn't expect Jack's teacher, Miss Lily, to be a young beauty who knows just how to take old Arthur Morgan apart.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 4,874
- Chapters:
- 3/?
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 8
- Kudos:
- 34
- Bookmarks:
- 9
- Hits:
- 641
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
07 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Dutch’s daughter has spent the past decade of her life in New York, receiving the kind of education Dutch could only dream of for his precious daughter. As a refined, educated young woman she returns to the gang, out of place and unpracticed in their way of life. In Arthur’s opinion, she fits in just fine.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
07 Feb 2026
-
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
02 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
After being dragged into a session of Spin the Bottle against his will, Arthur is tasked with kissing you.
-
Basically some first kiss fluff inspired by THAT ONE episode of New Girl with Jess & Nick's first kiss, if you know you know
(And Sean and Kieran are alive and well at Shady Belle)
-Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
01 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
The gang's spending the evening at the saloon, but you and a certain cowboy can't seem to take your eyes off each other.
Series
- Part 6 of Writer Wednesday
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
31 Jan 2026
-
Open Roads and Impolite Company by The_Drowsy_Captain
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
19 May 2022
Tags
Summary
Hiding in the employee bathroom until your shift ends you come across a man with the absolute worst profile on a dating app. By some sheer coincidence, he's just as bored as you, and planning a fishing trip!
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
30 Jan 2026
-
enigma — arthur morgan x reader by honey_hanlon024
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), Red Dead Redemption 2
01 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
⊹ ࣪ ˖ the year is 1890 and you find yourself as the newest member of the ever growing van der linde gang.
e•nig•ma l i'nigma, e'nigma |
noun (plural enigmas) a person or thing that is mysterious, puzzling, or difficult to understand.updates often!! i’m also on wattpad & tumblr.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
30 Jan 2026
-
What the Water Gave Me by MileyCyprus_Hill
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption 2, rdr2 - Fandom, Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
14 Aug 2020
Tags
Summary
Months ago, I decided to write a cliché fic inspired by a dream I had where Arthur woke up on the beaches of Guarma. I guess my brain wanted a RDR2/Little Mermaid crossover. It’s corny, I know. This is just a preview from my notes, so constructive criticism is very appreciated! I’ll post more previews instead of unloading it in one big post. I don’t even know if I’ll actually make it into an actual fic. But I had fun. Hope formatting looks alright as I’m transferring my works from my Tumblr page. Enjoy!
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
28 Jan 2026
-
What the Water Gave Me by MileyCyprus_Hill
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption 2, rdr2 - Fandom, Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
14 Aug 2020
Tags
Summary
Months ago, I decided to write a cliché fic inspired by a dream I had where Arthur woke up on the beaches of Guarma. I guess my brain wanted a RDR2/Little Mermaid crossover. It’s corny, I know. This is just a preview from my notes, so constructive criticism is very appreciated! I’ll post more previews instead of unloading it in one big post. I don’t even know if I’ll actually make it into an actual fic. But I had fun. Hope formatting looks alright as I’m transferring my works from my Tumblr page. Enjoy!
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
28 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You were Dutch’s girl. He made that clear. Each job seemed to wear on him as every success and failure made him more reckless as his need for power grew. But for however reckless Dutch was, you were more so, as you found yourself in the arms of another. The loyalty both you and Arthur swore to Dutch was shattered as the fire of your own making consumed you both. The promise of that happy ending was now in tatters and you knew that it would not be long before your actions would begin to have consequences.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
28 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You are sixteen when you meet Arthur Morgan, the boy who will change your life forever.
17-year-old Arthur Morgan finds a creepy girl in need of some rescuing after a nasty shoot out. In a move no one expected, he ends up falling in love in the process. Whoops.
Series
- Part 13 of Bewitched and Befallen, Home To You
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
27 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
“He made her bleed.” Arthur’s voice is grave. He grabs the man at the back of the neck with a crushing hold, paying him back tenfold when the man snatched your wrist from before. “You fucking grabbed her like this right?” The man’s flails around in Arthur’s grasp.
-----
Dutch owns a popular night club, with Arthur as its bouncer. You're Dutch's prized possession, and when you run in to some trouble at the club, Arthur comes to the rescue. When he gets you alone, he realizes why Dutch keeps you so close.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
26 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Arthur picks up your precious jeweled comb, leading to a chance encounter between the two of you. He thought you were the stuff of legends.
Reader is a mermaid.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
26 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
"A dozen Fatui researchers are dying to get ahold of you," says Alhaitham. "The only reason you're safe in my bed, instead of being dissected on an operating table, is because I declared that you're under my protection."
He yanks on Kaveh's hair. "Don't make me regret it."
Or, Kaveh is captured by Alhaitham, a member of the Fatui.
Note: Major Character Death
Series
- Part 1 of Fatui!Alhaitham
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
04 Nov 2023
-
Tags
Summary
Their relationship was twisted and tangled in ways that many around them did not fully comprehend. But they did not ask them to.
Each one between the three of them got what they wanted out of the entanglement, and in a world where the nights seem longer than any day having a bit of company to go by is a blessing. Or a curse, if you were to grow addicted to it.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
26 Apr 2023
-
take my breath, baby reach inside my chest by eerie_enchantress
Fandoms: TOUCHSTARVED (Red Spring Studio Visual Novel)
15 Apr 2023
Tags
Summary
After your little escapade with Ais outside of the bar, you return back inside to find that Vere is, against all your expectations, somehow still there.
Too bad you could never leave well enough alone.
Series
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
24 Apr 2023
-
Blood and Woodsmoke by sirenalley
Fandoms: TOUCHSTARVED (Red Spring Studio Visual Novel)
01 Apr 2023
Tags
Summary
When he met the Monster named Ais, Eridia’s weather was dour and gray overhead, and he was loose from his leash.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
23 Apr 2023
-
Tags
Summary
"Ais."
Sucking on air, Ais does his best to keep his composure as he feels his clothed cock being suddenly grasped and tugged by Vere where people cannot see.
"I said I'm bored."Or, Ais is about to pick up a fight at the bar again, and Vere figures it would be waaay better if all that energy goes for a something a little more fun instead.
Bookmarked by plckyourfilter
23 Apr 2023