1 - 20 of 1,109 Works in Jonathan Crane/Edward Nygma
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
"The night was when his father came. Like clockwork, the sun would set and the drunken thing inside his father would rise."
It truly was an irrational thing, but over time, Edward had developed a Phobia of the dark. It was always dark when his father got drunk and beat him half to death. And it was always dark when Batman came to take him away. Jonathan isn’t sure whether to exploit or help him.
Series
- Part 5 of Loganisbored's Whumptober 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Edward Nygma, is better known as the Riddler, but he is also known as one hell of a Radio host.
Especially when his show can be known to bring on just about any of Gotham's rogues, whether he wants them to or not.Set in a slightly bastadised script format
Technically each chapter is an episode and can be read alone or in any order [especially as these are uploaded out of order according to the timeline.Series
- Part 1 of EnRiddled Verse
-
Paranormal My Ass by Dot_Burn
Fandoms: Batman (Comics), DCU (Comics), DCU, Batman - All Media Types
05 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Fictober day 3: “I don’t need a reason.”
Edward has to explain his choice in friend to the other Rouges of the underground. Unfortunetly, despite being the fear Scarecrow, Jonathan is all that in the monster community.
In other words Edward has to balance be a feared Villainess Sphinx and keeping this pesky little human alive. Why was Jon insist on visting the underground.
Aka Monster au where Jonathan's not the monster (physically).
Series
-
Loyalty and The Lack Of It by Anonymous
Fandoms: Batman (Comics), Gotham City Sirens (Comics), Batman - All Media Types
04 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Edward Nygma wasn’t loyal to anyone but himself and his intellect. Harley knew that, but chose to trust him regardless after she escaped from Arkham and needed a place to stay. It prompts her to compare it to her own loyalties.
-
Tags
Summary
So…Three villains walk into a bedroom.
Series
- Part 3 of AvidPayGornWatchers Kinktober 2025
-
Selfie by Anonymous
Fandoms: The Batman (Movie 2022), Batman (Movies - Nolan), Batman - All Media Types
04 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
After escaping Arkham together, Edward wants Jonathan to appear on his live stream! Jonathan is completely against the idea.
-
Tags
Summary
Jonathan snakes his hand into Edward’s hair and yanks his head back. It earns him another gasp. “You’re welcome to plead your case if you like, darlin’," he says with a cruel twist of his mouth. "Tell me why I should give you what you so desperately crave.”
OR: A breakout at Arkham gives Edward and Jonathan enough time to enjoy each other's company. Or rather, Jonathan enjoys himself at Edward's expense—and Edward isn't quiet about how much he hates him for it.
-
Echo's Kinktober 2025 by MindTheEcho
Fandoms: X-Men '97 (Cartoon 2024), X-Men - All Media Types, X-Men (Comicverse), Batman - All Media Types, Superman - All Media Types, Superman (Movie 2025), Sherlock (TV), Malevolent (Podcast), She-Ra and the Princesses of Power (2018)
02 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
A collection of multifandom Kinktober fics
2/29 complete
-
Older Guys Are Way More Fun by Crashingthisbane (Sitarsitar)
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types
02 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
When you’ve spent your entire teenage years obsessed with someone, and the chance finally comes to break them out of an asylum, why wouldn’t you take it?
-
Only Idiots Can Be Hypnotized by wizardspells888
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, DCU, DCU (Comics), Batman (Comics)
01 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
While bragging about a recent scheme, Edward declares that only idiots can be hypnotized and, since he is soooo smart and also a genius, he cannot be. Joker proves him wrong. Everyone watching immediately takes advantage of the situation and puts Edward to the humiliating task of pleasing all of their whims.
"We watched the Riddler get hypnotized and all we got was this triple penetration."
-
hattercrow Stories by catlove99
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, The Batman (Cartoon 2004), Batman: Arkham (Video Games)
01 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Just hattercrow stories
-
An Unhealthy Obsession by ilikeglapes
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, Batman (Movies - Nolan), The Batman (Movie 2022)
01 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Jonathan Crane meets an interesting man in the library, and can see there are layers behind the carefully constructed façade, but it's far too deeper for him to see. He'll just have to dig deeper.
Edward Nashton knows Jonathan Crane. The psychiatrist letting Carmine Falcone's men into Arkham Asylum rather than their failed justice system. He wants to kill him. He wants to meet Scarecrow.
-
Tags
Summary
Annabel is tired. A fact not helped by the glowering, impatient Riddler sitting in her and her dad’s kitchen waiting for her to eat breakfast. Why is she in this situation at 2:30 in the morning you might ask? She sort of wants to know too. At the moment the easiest answer is simple: Her dad needs some Fear Toxin to break out of Arkham Asylum, and Eddie needs her to make it.
Or: Jonathan Crane found a kid with no self-preservation, said “Is anyone gonna raise that?”, and got no reply. Unfortunately, she now wants in on the “family business” and has decided she’s gonna befriend Robin at the same time. Somehow.
-
The Mice Will Play by SmallestRose
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, DCU (Comics), The Flash - All Media Types
28 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
The Gotham City Sirens have a group chat! Surely Harley Quinn won't make things too chaotic when she tries to invite some more friends.
Tags will be updated as more chapters are added.
-
Tags
Summary
”Two months. Or more precisely, two months, three days and twelve hours. A sliver of the year had passed, and Jonathan had not seen any sign of Edward for all that time.”
It had been two months since Edward had vanished without a trace. When Jonathan finds his broken phone lost in the back alleys of Gotham, he's forced into action.
-
DC Mini-Fics by Gilver
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, The Batman (Movie 2022), Batman: Arkham (Video Games), Batman: The Animated Series, Gotham (TV), DCU (Comics), Justice League - All Media Types, Green Lantern - All Media Types, The Flash - All Media Types
17 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Using this to archive my DC words; any fics under 1000 words and HCs.
Some are as old as 2015, most are new.
A mix of character/reader and character/character.
Character and relationship tags will be updated with each post. -
My House, My Rules by wizardspells888
Fandoms: Batman - All Media Types, Batman (Comics), DCU
14 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Edward is staying at Jonathan's because the wifi at his place is out.
The fic in which Jonathan cooks Edward dinner. And they might be in love??
-
I Love You, Let Me Brush Your Hair by Atrenchcoatfilledwithbees
Fandoms: DCU, Batman (Comics), Batman - All Media Types
14 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
One of Ed’s favourite things in the world is running his fingers through Jonathan’s hair. Unfortunately, the burlap of his mask makes this difficult, the rough fabric leaving his hair tangled and knotted.
So, one night, Ed decides to take matters into his own hands, and methodically work Jonathan’s hair into softness, so that he can better card his hands through the dark locks. -
Tags
Summary
Early on in Jonathan and Edward’s semi-stable criminal partnership, Edward agrees to willingly take some of Jonathan’s fear toxin in an overconfident gesture of proving himself. It both does and does not go as planned.
-
I Need You Like I Need: by PanicProne
Fandoms: DCU (Comics), Batman - All Media Types, Batman (Comics)
10 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Edward wanted to ask too many questions at once.
He wanted to ask about the scars. He wanted to know if Jonathan would still work with him after this—or if the fallout had finally outweighed the reward. He wondered if the man resented him for things beyond his control.
But more than anything, he just wanted to know if Jonathan would be okay.
Anxiety wiggled in his gut at the realization that had he fallen just the right way, he could have died.
The scarecrow, dead. Jonathan, dead.
His heart pounded and his stomach churned at the acknowledgement of fear.
He cared about Jonathan Crane.
He cared more than he’d cared about anyone before.
_____
After a heist goes sideways, leaving Edward with a concussion and Jonathan with a broken leg, the two men are forced to recover together in one of Jon's old abandoned safehouses. As they patch each other up and get on each other’s nerves, Edward struggles to hide a secret: he’s in love with Jonathan Crane.