15 Bookmarks by Simpleshortbread
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
The spell Pure Vanilla uses to stop Dark Enchantress ends up with some side effects that he wasn't expecting.
As for the Fount of Knowledge, a strange cookie has appeared in the lands with no memories and a magic he's never seen before. He must study him!
Series
- Part 1 of I'll Love You Again and Again (Series)
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 50,099
- Chapters:
- 22/22
- Comments:
- 780
- Kudos:
- 2,351
- Bookmarks:
- 312
- Hits:
- 46,232
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
09 Mar 2026
-
Tags
Summary
After a spell gone wrong, Shadow Milk and the Sage of Truth end up swapping places in their realities. Now they, along with Pure Vanilla and Truthless Recluse, have to find a spell to bring the two cookies back to their own realities.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 31,030
- Chapters:
- 11/11
- Collections:
- 4
- Comments:
- 422
- Kudos:
- 3,628
- Bookmarks:
- 504
- Hits:
- 52,951
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
08 Mar 2026
-
Tags
Summary
"No one does anything without wanting something in return," he continued. "So what are you expecting from me?"
Pure Vanilla's smile grew. "Oh, that's easy!" he said. "I want you to trust me."
-Drabble Collection for DeceitfulTruthTober 2025. Each chapter is a different prompt fill.
Series
- Part 3 of Muse's CRK Stories
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
08 Mar 2026
-
so many fishes in the sea (so why can't one of them be mine???) by kuipermoth
Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)
15 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
I am the single worst title writer ever please bear with me yes I know it's cringe since hes a fish literally shut up okay okay yeah okay shush close your m-
Blueberry Milk Cookie, former professor and most clever sailor on the sea (by no one's standards but his own, of course), meets the fabled Mer of legend, the former holder of the Soul-Shell of Absolute Truth and Knowledge... a very pathetic, very injured Cookie by the simple name of Recluse.
Of course, he has no idea this is the very man he literally tells stories about to his students. All he knows is that he is very normal about the first Mer he's ever met.inspired by an AU me, skittle, and long came up with!!! if yall ever read this hiiii :3
Series
- Part 7 of kuiper is normal about truthlesssage
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
23 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Moving was always difficult, no matter who or what you were.
Red Velvet experienced the troubles and difficulty first hand as an unclaimed, single omega with two kids. He knew he was moving four hours away from his support system to a small town where everyone knows everyone, so he was preparing himself for the gossip.
He wasn't prepared for the kindness he received.
And he certainly wasn't prepared for the love.
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
19 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
“How wonderful!! Afterwards you can help me with errands too! I need to get some groceries, visit the flower shop…” Pure Vanilla chirped as he continued to list chores one after another making the beast go from flushed to deathly pale.
What had his jealousy signed him up to?!
He just wanted a lazy day in bed!!
“—and then we will come back home just in time for dinner!”
Dinner?!
Shadow Milk really didn't want to go through all that trouble today… but how could he possibly say no when Pure Vanilla looked so happy just to spend time with him?
---
OR: join Pure Vanilla and Shadow Milk as they spend a regular day together from waking up to falling back asleep.
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
16 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
The night before they depart, Pure Vanilla stumbles upon a breakthrough. A book, burned and scarred from the ages, but detailing the proper steps to starting a relationship. Dating back to Shadow Milk’s time, perhaps this will let him break past the other’s shell and finally make have the other take him up on his offer of friendship! All he has to do is follow these steps, and they should be friends in no time, as the book says!
Shadow Milk, for his part, is thrown by his counterpart suddenly flipping the script and trying to woo him.
Series
- Part 1 of Of Courtings and Confusion
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 63,901
- Chapters:
- 11/?
- Comments:
- 706
- Kudos:
- 4,398
- Bookmarks:
- 796
- Hits:
- 84,657
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
13 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Shadow Milk was not a man who understood the concept of mercy.
To him, it was a word soaked in bitterness, a concept so foreign and sharp, stinging even in thought. Mercy never came for him when he needed it most. Now, with the collapse of his spire, Shadow Milk is left with nothing except a hand, soft and steady, extended in the wake of ruin. But trust doesn’t rebuild itself overnight. Not after betrayal. Not after not knowing anything else for centuries.
It falls to Pure Vanilla to tend to wounds long left to rot. But does a mere healer such as himself have the ability to achieve that?
[Updates once every full moon]
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
12 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Truthless Recluse finally decides to visit the Sage after three years. He ends up getting a lot more than he bargained for.
WARNING! for freaky sage of truth
Series
- Part 2 of oops! all shadowvanilla!
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
10 Jan 2026
-
A Piece of You: A Piece of Me (PVSM Kid Fics) by Just_A_Tired_Person
Fandom Cookie Run (Video Game)
25 Oct 2025
Summary
Same universe as 'Running Away; Returning Home', where Pure Vanilla and Shadow Milk try to mend their relationship after a falling out in college. Oh, and Shadow Milk has a daughter he never told Pure Vanilla about.
- Words:
- 53,742
- Works:
- 8
- Bookmarks:
- 46
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
10 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
OR: Truthless is a doll and Shadow send him to spy on the ancients!
✨✨✨
🎭~~🌹~~🎭
“WHAT?!”
Pure Vanilla’s voice, sharp with anger, burst through the door.
Lily’s heart jumped. She’d never heard him angry before. Not like that.
“No... No, no! You said I’d be here for two months!” he snapped. “Now you’re asking me to stay for a year?! It’s hard enough pretending to be happy—but staying here for a whole year?”
Lily’s breath caught.
Staying here instead of going where?
She instinctively cast an invisibility spell and slipped through the door, silent as wind.
Pure Vanilla—or whoever he was now—stood with his back to her, shoulders rigid, hands clenched. He looked... disheveled. Angry. Frustrated.
“I don’t want to be here!” he shouted. “I feel my obedience slipping, and these Cookies... They’re nice! It’s too much. I don’t like it. The mask you told me to wear is becoming realer every day!”
A soft, mocking voice responded.
“Ohhhh, my little Recluse wants to come home?” Shadow Milk crooned through the deceit eye. “Do you miss your master that much?”
Lily’s heart dropped like a stone.
Master?
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
10 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
What lingers first in Pure Vanilla’s memory are two eyes— cyan and blue.
They were not simply colors, not merely shades to be catalogued among the blossoms that lined the Vanilla hills. They were shadows caught in ice, stars buried in snow. And in the middle of all that frost, a boy who looked too small for the crown that would one day press against his brow, eyes too large for the timid boy who held them.
Pure Vanilla had not known then that love could strike so young.
He had thought it the sort of thing that bloomed late, like the orchids that only flowered when the sun coaxed them after patient months of waiting.
But with Shadow Milk, it was not coaxed— it was immediate.
Pure Vanilla is six, and he knows he's in love.
(It never changes)
Series
- Part 7 of My Cookie Works
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 114,645
- Chapters:
- 5/8
- Comments:
- 249
- Kudos:
- 1,035
- Bookmarks:
- 257
- Hits:
- 27,057
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
10 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
My take on Flufftober/Whumptober/Kinktober. I'm doing a conglomeration of all of them!
All of the chapters will be centered around Pure Vanilla, as well as most of them being ShadowVanilla related.
More information will be in the first chapter, as well as my prompt list!Credits to borgor_25's "Polytober!" for the initial inspiration of this combination of all three. Go read it if you haven't, it's great!
(Despite the title, this is not confined to October, it's done when I hit prompt 31)
{ 2/21/2026 Edit: Currently on hiatus for an undetermined amount of time, check the updated first chapter for details}
Series
- Part 3 of Kat's Avian Pure Vanilla Works
- Part 3 of Sealed Fates
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
10 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Pure Vanilla visits White Lily to talk about his growing feelings for Shadow Milk. She doesn't understand but if he was willing to stand up to all of them and give the Beast a chance to change then she supposes she has no other choice but to support him. Unfortunately for them, her faerie subjects get the wrong idea of why the two Ancients are meeting more frequently and decide to take matters into their own hands.
A potion to bring forth hidden affections given to the one cookie that has some form of love for every single person he's ever known means now White Lily has to try and keep an increasingly cuddly Pure Vanilla from embarrassing himself in front of everyone he crosses paths with. And when Shadow Milk shows up, she needs to keep him from making a mistake that may just drive the jester away for good.
Pure Vanilla is lucky she's always been good at figuring out spell craft... and with an extremely reluctant Shadow Milk's help, maybe they can break this lovestruck haze that her friend is trapped in.
AKA
Someone wanted Viridescent Outfit PV but with the ShadowVanilla ship. I decided to make it thousands of words of angst repairing many cookie's relationships while I'm at it.Series
- Part 1 of Veridian Dreaming
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 88,391
- Chapters:
- 19/?
- Comments:
- 1,298
- Kudos:
- 3,078
- Bookmarks:
- 572
- Hits:
- 101,840
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
10 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
There weren't a lot of things that truly scared Pure Vanilla.
Yes, he had the normal, average fears like losing his loved ones. Or of hurting those he cared about. However, those were normal.
But... one thing he had never been able to shake was his fear of cages. Shackles didn't bother him much, but bars encircling him from all angles made his chest tighten with raw, primal fear.
He knew why this was, of course, but had long since left that part of his past behind.
However, one night... something prompts him to finally open up about what exactly happened that dreaded week.
Series
- Part 6 of Kat's Avian Pure Vanilla Works
Bookmarked by Simpleshortbread
10 Jan 2026